Jun 18, 2008

Annoying Riding Princess Death Match! or TB #26: Sterling's Second Chance

Sterling's Second Chance
Thoroughbred #26
by Allison Estes
Published: 1998

When Joanna Campbell plunked Moe down in the Thoroughbred Series out of her real life I was okay with that. When Karen Bentley erased Cindy's less annoying personality and replaced it with her own, that really pissed me off. In The Horse of her Dreams, Allison Estes tossed Maureen Mack into the fold, and in this book Cassidy Smith moved from her home in Florida to muck up the lives of our charmingly obtuse characters. I can't help but think that as Allison wrote this book, she was thinking: "Now I will surely be Cassidy's most favorite aunt! Who else would pander to a child's ego so effectively? No one, that's who!"

So I find it curious when the authors stick real people in these books, making it incredibly easy to cyberstalk those they were so eager to please by immortalizing them in print. Although, really, that's not the issue here. It's our wonderful fictional characters and their reaction to our most recent real life implant, Cassidy, that makes the story. To the cover!


Yeah, I don't care. Gray horse, little girl, no chin strap, blah blah blah.
Does Christina have the heart of a champion?

Christina Reese is sure she and her new horse, Sterling Dream, are ready for their first competition. Then Christina is injured in a fall and loses both her nerve and her spot on the team. Someone needs to ride Sterling, or the team will be disqualified.

When beautiful, self-confident Cassidy Smith is picked to ride Sterling in the show, Christina tries to be a good sport. But it's not easy. Cassidy is claiming that both Christina and Sterling are quitters. Will Christina and her horse get the chance to prove just how wrong Cassidy is?
The thing about this blurb is that the whole second half of it never happens. I don't know how exactly this whole blurb process works -- if the blurb is written before the story or the story is written before the blurb, but it is very clear that someone wasn't in line. Cassidy Smith isn't "picked" to ride Sterling and Christina and Sterling don't set out to prove anyone wrong. Basically, the whole book is about Christina acting like a paranoid freak of nature, which brings me to the title. This thing should be called Christina's Second Chance or Sterling Gets Annoyed With Her Bipolar Rider, because Sterling's Second Chance implies that the horse was doing something wrong at the beginning of the story when really she was just behaving as any horse would when a complete lunatic is sitting on its back.

Plot:

Sterling is so great! She's been off the track for weeks and is training fantastically for her super shiny career in (E)venting, so Christina is all besides herself with glee only she is also crippled by a very annoying inability to treat the horse like anything other than Waterford crystal. Picking up on this, Sterling starts to test her limits and Christina isn't prepared for Sterling's moody shenanigans. But why would Sterling decide to test Christina's awesome magical riding ability? Isn't Sterling supposed to be Christina's uber special mare she's waited her whole twelve years for? She just does. not. get it!

So the issue is that Sterling keeps ducking out and refusing to take jumps. Mona's solution to this is relatively simple: a) carry a crop when you ride and b) hit the damn horse with the crop when it does something you don't want it to do. When Christina hears this stunningly realistic logic she immediately does our typical Thoroughbred character whining about abuse and how she promised herself she'd never hit poor Sterling with anything ever because Christina isn't an ugly backside groom with bad teeth, she is a horse riding princess! Hitting her wonder horse is beneath her! Sterling should just magically know what Christina wants, or so she thinks. It doesn't work out that way, so for the first three or four chapters of the book they basically wrestle each other in a truly stunning display of horsemanship antics that can't possibly hope to be followed. Mona gets annoyed with this and tells Christina to get off the horse. She's going to teach the mare something, and Christina's all weepy and tells Mona not to hit Sterling and Mona's all "yeah, whatever."

While Mona's off perfectly riding Sterling, Christina takes some time to feel offended, angry and instantly suspicious of our new character, Cassidy. Cassidy is perfect, and has already won at the National Horse Show, which Christina is instantly jealous of to the point that she decides Cassidy is lying. So Mona shows back up to make Christina ride Sterling again, but Christina is too busy convincing herself that Dylan and Cassidy are holding hands to pay much attention to the water jump she's supposed to be jumping which ends in disaster. Mona tells her to get off the damn horse because Christina is acting like a loon, but Christina ignores her and tries it again and fails even more miserably. She falls off the horse and actually breaks her wrist and boo hoo she's hurt for the first time ever.

Christina has to have a cast for two weeks, which is the end of the world because she can't ride. Since Christina has no other hobbies and is remarkably two-dimensional, you can imagine how awful this is for her. So it comes up that someone has to ride Sterling to keep her in training, and Mona instantly suggests Cassidy because she's just great and everyone loves her, much to Christina's agitation. Like hell that perfect girl is going to ride Christina's supposedly once perfect horse! She essentially tells Mona this and proceeds to ask everyone else she knows, and everyone else tells her they're busy because they all have lives outside of horses, leaving Christina in her two-dimensional world with no horse to ride. Only then she finds out that Dylan and Cassidy are going out to the movies together, and she hates Cassidy even more. That sort-of boyfriend stealing slut!

But never fear, Melanie is to the rescue. Despite Christina's completely annoying insistence that no one knows Sterling like she does and whatever else, she finally relents and lets Melanie groom the mare before she makes Melanie exercise her. Then there's another episode of shrieking and shooting looks at people and Sterling bolts around the paddock with Melanie clinging to her neck as Cassidy steps in to save the day for our two heroic and yet completely clueless main characters. Melanie's had it after Christina's shrieking fit and leaves, so now Christina has no one to ride her super precious persnickety mare...until she comes to the stable the next day to see Cassidy riding Sterling! Holy hell! How dare they, everyone and Sterling for letting that sort-of boyfriend stealing girl get on her back like that! Everyone is at fault except Christina, or so she thinks, as she has visions of dragging Cassidy off the horse. Cassidy, having a heightened sense of self preservation, gets off the horse and lets Christina haul Sterling back to the stable.

So, just as it's become stunningly apparent that Christina has lost it entirely, Melanie rides to the rescue again and tells Christina she has to let Cassidy ride the horse if she's going to enter this Foxwood event thingy when her cast comes off. Christina swallows her pride and calls Cassidy up, apologizes for her insane behavior, and Cassidy tells her she just can't help because she's still unpacking from moving or something incredibly made up. I don't blame her for not wanting to ride...we're dealing with an unbalanced twelve-year-old girl here and there's nothing more frightening. Dejected, Christina goes to mope with Sterling. Then Cassidy has her random change of heart and decides to ride. Just like that, everything is super fantastic again!

Only then Christina's cast comes off and she's paralyzed with fear. She just can't ride Sterling and insists that Cassidy ride in the show instead. Everyone seems to wait for her natural outburst, but when that doesn't come they know something's really up and go about secretly plotting to make Christina ride in the show. Their plot is revealed at the absolute last second, and it all works out because Cassidy wears the same size as Christina. Marvelous! So they force Christina onto the horse at the show, she rides around like she's on acid or something equally hallucinogenic, and finally has to use that crop she's been freaking out about and wins the show because she's a super riding princess and it's a given. Then Dylan kisses her on the cheek and the nervous butterflies in her stomach become joyful butterflies, but no one notices, thank God.

Oddities:

  • Melanie actually asks what Cassidy means when she says one of her two horses is still a little green. Sure, Melanie is supposed to be the one who isn't as knowledgeable as everyone else, but really? No. It's not a term that's applied solely to horses. She should know what it means in general.
  • The whole hang up in this book is the riding crop. If Christina had just shut up and done as asked from the get go this book wouldn't have been necessary. For as stupid and touchy as Christina assumes Sterling is, she is remarkably not stupid and touchy.
  • When Christina goes down to the track to watch Melanie pony with Pirate, Ashleigh actually gets all excited and wonders aloud if Christina has finally decided to take up racing. This is just really pathetic. Yeah, Ashleigh, after she traded Wonder's last foal for a horse she can event with she'll take up racing. That's likely.
  • Christina was channeling her inner Cindy in this book to a serious degree. All the hissing and glaring and attempting withering looks...she was on a roll. The only difference was she was trying to be a bitch whereas with Cindy it just came naturally.

That is all here. I'll be back with Christina's Courage next, and a few other books that involve perfect thirteen-year-old girls riding magnificent horses and fixing everyone's lives and whatnot. Good times will be had by all, I'm sure.

Want more? Monique's review of Sterling's Second Chance is here.

Jun 17, 2008

Joanna Campbell does teen romance in The Thoroughbred, much to my utter vexation.

The Thoroughbred
Bantam Sweet Dreams Romance #8
by Joanna Campbell
Published: 1981

Because I just can't get out of the 1980's lately, my next installment is Joanna Campbell's The Thoroughbred. This book is as old as I am (actually, it's younger by about five months), the main character's name is the Irish version of mine (which never fails to creep me out just a little bit), and I have no idea why this is called The Thoroughbred...it could have been called Pretty Black Pony for all the title has to do with the story.


As far as I could tell there is no easily attainable photo of this cover on the internet. Since I have no scanner (horrors!), here's my best reproduction of it using my super duper camera's close up application. I don't know why I bothered, really, other than this horrible need I have to document everything. I could have just said: "Imagine a blond you wearing a burgundy sweater and tweed jacket. Now imagine you wearing these items in 1981." That probably would have done the trick right there.


Maura is rich and pretty, but that means nothing when she has to compete against the boy she loves...

Things have always come easy for Maura -- good looks, good grades and a real talent for horseback riding. So when she and her friend Jill start their summer at a horse farm, Maura decides she's going to win first prize in the annual horse show.

Then Maura meets Kevin, a dark, handsome boy who rides as if he was born on a horse. Riding with Kevin is like dancing with a wonderfully graceful partner, and for the first time Maura falls in love. But Kevin wants too much from her too soon and she's scared. She needs a little breathing space.

Feeling rejected, Kevin decides to show Maura up by winning the prize that she has been working towards all summer. But Maura is determined to win, even if it means losing the first boy she's ever really loved.
This summary is absolutely too long for this book. That, or I'm so used to those stunted Thoroughbred blurbs that thorough summaries are foreign to me now. But then when I think this all I have to do is read that second paragraph again and I immediately start to make a horribly sour face right at "riding with Kevin is like..." because I really do no think so. I mean, come on. Dancing with a wonderfully graceful partner? Please.

Okay. First things first. Maura is a rich sixteen-year-old blond girl from Connecticut. She's a boarding school kid at a place called Maryvale and goes there with her best friend, Jill. She could own a horse, but chooses not to because she would only be able to ride this horse two times a week, which essentially is chalked up as abuse. Because Maura is so kind hearted she decides it's best not to own any horses, despite her earth shattering riding skills. Jill is the girl with the MG and the horse family background, who rides but doesn't really care about it, and will eventually be a very spunky whore when she grows up.

This summer Maura decides to pass up yet another opportunity to spend her summer in Europe so she can spend her time at Jill's uncle's horse farm in Danbury. There she instantly bonds with a mare called Blackfire after one ride, mainly because Maura is that finely tuned as a rider. She does everything perfectly. She is perfect. SUBLIMELY PERFECT. It is frightening. Even at the country club, she swims and dives perfectly. She tans perfectly. She looks beautiful in her white bikini...really, I think I sort of hate her. Anyway, moving on.

So, the farm is hosting this big summer show and Alex (Jill's uncle) decides that Maura is talented enough to enter the open jumping competition, which is the most fantabulous competition there is ever. Maura, being perfect, twitters about how she's just not that good and Alex is all, "shut it, you're competing in the show" and she acquiesces. Soon after this, Jill and Maura go riding around the countryside and happen upon this beautiful farm. Maura, being perfect, doesn't want to trespass, but Jill, being flawed, is all "to hell with that" and they trespass. Our typical male hero arrives to tell them they're trespassing on his daddy's farm, mocks them severely, takes some time to be grudgingly humbled/shocked that Maura is going to enter the open jumping show, and then sneers at them for good measure. Yes, it does sound like Brad Townsend has traveled back in time (although, by my calculations, Brad would be about five in 1981...not that I'm obsessed or anything), appearing here as the dark, handsome, arrogant neighbor that Maura has to clash wish because he's pompous and she's all perfect and annoying. Never fear! This guy is no Brad Townsend. This guy is Kevin DeAngelo, an incredibly horrible result of everything that's bad about Irish and Italian genes mixing. Honestly, say it with me. Kevin DeAngelo. Doesn't it make you want to scream and break something? If not, maybe it's just me. Or maybe it's my sheer hatred of the name Kevin. Or maybe it's the Irish first name with the Italian last name. Or maybe it's ALL of it. Yeah, that's probably it.

Anyway. After their clash with dear old "I wish I was Brad" Kevin, Jill is all pleased that he insulted her and Maura is damn certain she'll never be one of those many girls that fall at his feet because he has broad shoulders and tons of money. No sir. She'll die first. It's exactly like listening to Ashleigh whenever she always had to state that she never could understand why people thought Brad was attractive. At least Maura stops protesting when it becomes blatantly obvious that she wants to fall at his feet like all the others.

I don't really remember how they actually get together...it's something pretty basic, I know that much. He starts coming over to the farm where Maura is staying so he can practice on his horse, and eventually he asks her out on a ride and that morphs into other things and finally he becomes the absolute opposite of sexy snobby Brad wannabe and becomes a clingy, possessive asshole who whines too much. They decide to meet up at a pool party and he's late, so Maura finds herself talking to Bill (whom she thinks is perfect for Jill, although that will never work because their names together make me cringe), and Bill asks her out but before she can reply Kevin shows up to stake his claim like the infuriatingly insecure but painted as confident romantic hero he is, which pisses off Maura. That doesn't last for long, despite him being upset that she wasn't waiting for him at the party...like, what? Around here I was getting some really disturbing feelings that he's just waiting to morph into his final stage of creepiness...the physical abuser.

But just wait! Oh, just wait. So Kevin becomes more clingy, and Maura gets more flighty, and he eventually convinces her to come meet his folks in their palatial mansion. She agrees to this, has dinner with them all, suffers through his parents mock-threatening to kill each other (slowly, by grinding up glass and sticking it in food...nice detail, Joanna!) and then goes out on a walk with Kevin which somehow ends up in a stream with them both half soaked. She gets pissy again and decides to go dry off in the grass and he plays around in the stream by himself (further proof that I think a few bolts are loose there) then romps back up to her, completely soaked and without a shirt. Because this is sexy, I guess. She opens her eyes and is all, oh...shirtless you. And he's all yes, I am shirtless. They proceed to make out in the grass and then (yes, and then...) he tries to date rape her. I know! Totally didn't see that coming either! But then I so obviously did. So she hauls off and hits him and demands that he take her home and I'm all, good for you! But she's all weepy because she loves him and really, what?

So she avoids him for a while until she decides to go swimming. She's swimming around in the club pool and out of nowhere he surfaces in front of her. Like...this is stalking on speed or something. This girl needs a PFA immediately. So he demands that she answer his question of if she'll "go with him" or whatever. You know, she's 16. He's 18 and attends Harvard. Isn't there a better phrase we can come up with for this? Or shouldn't she be hitting him again and telling him he creeps her out instead of being all forlorn when she blurts out no and he gets all annoyed so he just climbs out of the pool and walks straight to his car like he's not dripping wet all over the place? Who does that?

Then he starts dragging this ditzy 20-year-old blonde around with him everywhere, intent on hurting Maura's fragile feelings. Maura is in a state of sheer panic about this, but starts to avoid him even more and before you know it she's determined to beat him at the show, which I guess is a healthy reaction and so the show comes along and they do their show stuff and it comes down to Maura and Kevin. Like we all knew it would. There are two jump offs, increasing the heights of perfection to proportions I didn't know existed before, until Kevin's horse comes up lame and they concede to Maura, who accepts her "hollow" victory and refuses to go to the after party because she has to go sulk alone in the stable for a while about how she beat Kevin or whatever.

In the stable, as she's grooming Blackfire, Kevin miraculously appears and they make up while using all this flowery romance language that I am so burned out on that I am now positive this was a bad reading choice after all those Nora Roberts books. Anyway, Maura decides to belittle herself a little by telling him she's sure he would have won the show had his horse not come up lame (really? what?) and he tells her he was just trying to hurt her by dragging that stupid blond twenty-year-old around, and then they decide to write to each other and get together for Thanksgiving and Christmas and then they kiss and he tells her not to tell him all these feelings that she's been having (ie, that she loves him and has decided she wants to have a boyfriend and practice the piano and ride horses before she enters college to get her degree in music so she can become some rich person's wife and spend her time arranging flowers and doing whatever it is rich wives do). Only it doesn't matter because Blackfire approves of Kevin and Maura kissing and therefore we all should pretend that whole groping and slapping incident didn't happen and approve also.

And now, quote time!

Kevin's breathing became more rapid. He pulled his lips from hers for a moment and whispered hoarsely against her cheek, "Oh, Maura, Maura, I love you." His left hand moved her back and gently touched her breast.

Maura stiffened. She wasn't ready for this. She had to stop him before he went any further.

"Kevin," she gasped, pushing his hand away, "stop...please stop."

"Maura," he rasped huskily, "I love you...I need you."

"I'm not ready! Please..."

He began kissing her again. She closed her mouth tightly and tried to turn her head away. His kiss became more forceful.

"Kevin, stop! Stop!" She brought her hands around to his bare chest, trying to push him away. But he wouldn't move.

This wasn't the Kevin she knew. What was he doing? Why wouldn't he listen to her? In desperation she slapped him soundly across the cheek.

His head jerked. His eyes snapped wide as he suddenly lifted them to look down at her frightened face.

"Let me go, Kevin!"
~

I am so utterly disoriented. Not to mention? At this point Joanna Campbell is starting to make me feel dirty and I had no idea that was possible.

I need a Thoroughbred book and their ridiculous, sun shiny plots to ease the pain.

Jun 16, 2008

God Almighty, We’re Goin’ to the Races: The Race

Golden Filly Series #1: The Race
by Lauraine Snelling
First Printing: 1990

And now, I have to admit, I’m on a sugar high; one big chunky Rice Crispy square, and tea for breakfast. It’s the only thing that’s going to help me get through this review. To tell you the truth, I don’t even know why I have this book. I think I got it from my grandparents. They’re very religious, so it seems like something they’d get, because hey … it has a horse on the cover and is about horses, Lei must want to read it, right? Otherwise, I can’t figure out how this book ended up on my shelf, I know I’ve read some of the author’s High Hurdle series, but never really liked the author enough to want to read everything she’s written. Maybe it’s because she’s religious, and I’m not (well, not really, I’m sort of an agnostic-atheist, if that makes any sense) and I didn’t much like God shoved in my face like these books do.

Anyway, moving on...

Ye Olde Cover

Believe it or not, I can’t find this cover anywhere. At least in decent quality, the one on Amazon.com is hideous, so I fired up me old scanner, and scanned the darned thing. And it still came out looking ugly. Bethany House Publishers, you guys get a big fat F- for cover quality, mmkay. That said, it’s a confusing little cover. Tricia hasn’t got a helmet on, the horse apparently isn’t wearing a bridle, but somehow has a bit in his mouth (what’d they do, super glue it in?) and also, Spitfire seems to be channeling Perfect Image because he’s running the wrong way. Hello, cover designer… it’s a real purty track and all, but this is America, we run horses counterclockwise. I’d think a great slogan for this would be: Race Ridin: Ur Doin It Wrong!

Ye Olde Synopsis
Tricia Evanston has loved horses as long as she can remember just like her father. He has always encouraged her love of horse racing and has been training her to compete professionally. Things are not as smooth with Tricia's mother who worries about her schoolwork and the chances of her getting hurt. Their relationship is easily strained.

Tricia has turned sixteen and her whole life is about to be turned upside down. Her father has been coughing for a long time and finally goes to the hospital. The family is devastated when they learn the diagnosis. Tricia and her older brother David try to take care of the ranch, but when some of the horses get sick, Tricia's schoolwork really suffers.

And then there's the question of her faith. How can she trust in God when He's seemingly forgotten her father?

Before her looms the big race. If only she can win.
And blah blah blah. Hey, y’know, this synopsis is pretty accurate. Maybe we don’t have to read the book after all. Am I only dreaming there? Wibble. I am sad. ☹

Ye Olde Plot
So we start our story the way a lot of horse racing books begin, with a track scene in the morning. It seems to be an almost cookie-cutter formula for the “How Horse Racing Books Shall Start™” recipe. Maybe the authors feel they need to establish that this book is All About Racing.™ So anyway, it’s morning, and Tricia is riding a two-year-old (who is of course black because god forbid any horse be a normal bay color) with her father on this old gray horse (gee, are we cribbing from Walter Farley, here, Mrs. Snelling?) and the black colt dusts the older horse because obviously he’s a wonder horse. We then see that Tricia’s dad is having a coughing fit, which is undoubtedly going to be a problem for him later on. And we also have a nice little scene with the older brother, and the mom, and the mom is apparently worried sick about the thought of her daughter riding in a race. However, big brother tells her to fuck off because this is her daughter’s dream, and all, and how dare anybody ruin the precious dreams of a teenaged girl.

Tricia then goes to put the horse away so she can get ready for school, and finds her dad coughing up blood (see, I told you that coughing is going to be a problem) and gets worried. Tricia immediately starts praying like mad. And then she gets hustled off to school with her brother while her dad practically swears on a stack of bibles that he’s going to the doctor. At school, Tricia worries herself sick, talks with her best friend, Rhonda Seabolt, and then talks to this gorgeous boy named Brad that she’d probably want to screw if he wasn’t sort of like a brother, in which case it’d be sort of like incest (but not really) because any handsome intelligent male can only really be a good friend in a non-sexual way in a book written by a Christian. Oh yeah, and she realizes that she forgot to pray again, and beats herself up over it, mentally. And then it’s lunchtime, and she hangs out with the star quarterback jock named Doug whom she does want to screw because he’s not like a brother or anything. And then she has a panic attack and starts another prayerfest. And then it’s off to home, where she finds an empty house, along with a note from her brother saying her dad’s in the hospital. And this scares her because her family is apparently super healthy, and the only times they ever go to hospital is to die. So it’s time for another prayerfest. Whoot!

But it’s Brad to the rescue, and they take care of horses, and ride together and stuff. And then big brother David shows up, and tells them that daddy dearest is pretty much a goner because he has lung cancer (I bet you my weekly allowance that daddy was a chain smoker) and Tricia just happens to be on a horse, and has a meltdown, so the poor horse has a meltdown. And then it’s another prayerfest. And then to make matters worse, now they’ve got a horse that’s coughing. Wow, that just beats the dutch, don’t it? And it means another prayerfest. And the vet comes, and gives meds, and stuff.

And then Mumsy and the brother come back, and Mumsy has a shitfit about how her daughter didn’t go to the hospital. Mumsy also seems to be something of a feminine misogynist because she says flat out that “racing thoroughbreds is a man’s job” and Tricia flips her mom off and flounces off to her room because she’s Right and her mother is Wrong, so therefore, she’s got the right to flounce. And then Mommy comes in, and pretty much falls at her daughter’s feet to beg forgivness. And Tricia begins to fall behind in her schoolwork (dun dun dun… that’s sure to come back and bite her in the ass sooner or later.)

And now they’ve got more sick horses so they stick the lot in this old barn, and Tricia’s working like a mad thing to get everything taken care of. Oh, and she flunks a chemistry quiz. Like bad. Like so bad, she’s missed all but one question. Sucks to be her. And then she has an accident in the starting gate on a green colt, and eats dirt big time.

And then her dad gets home from the hospital, and he’s not doing so hot (he’s got cancer remember) so Tricia freaks because she didn’t go see him in hospital, so she’s shocked at how he looks, and flips out like ninja at her brother. And then instead of a prayerfest, it’s a hatefest because she tells God she hates him. Gasp! And then she goes for a ride on the old gray horse in a Western saddle. And then a few days later, she rides the horse that had a blowup in the gate, and everything goes well. And she seems to have mended her differences with God, because it’s a prayerfest again. And then the whole family goes to church, bully for them. And then she has her 16th birthday, and some of the football jocks try and kiss her at lunch time, and the entire school pretty much comes in their pants for her with all the cheering and whistling, and feet stamping and chanting about her winning her races and stuff.

And then it’s dinner at a seafood restaurant, and everyone gives Tricia race-related presents, from silks to a helmet and a whip. Oh my goodness, she really needs that whip does she? Even though she’s never even lifted or used one in the preceding 113 pages of this book. Hell, maybe she thought about using one on page one, but it’s not like she needed it with her ChampionSuperSpecialWonderHorse, right? And then one of their mares foals (in late September? Holy hell, Mrs. Snelling, do you know jackshit about horse racing or what?)

And finally, it’s off to the racetrack at last where they stable the horses, and then we cut to church where Mrs. Snelling reads us the usual regurgitated lecture about how much God cares for people, and how everyone needs to read the bible to find all of life’s answers, and blah blah blah. And Tricia gets in trouble in school, and her teacher threatens a smackdown. And her parents hire someone else to ride and do morning workouts. And then it’s back to the track for a horse race, and Tricia rides the pony horse to the gate, and then somehow remains on the track close enough for her brother and friends to be there. And of course, the horse wins, and the owner offers her the ride (even though we haven’t heard if she’s even got her jockey license yet.)

Tricia and her dad then have a heart-to-heart lovefest talk with Mount Saint Helens in the distance (man, talk about a downer. I’ve been to Mount Saint Helens, and this was a good 10 something years after the mountain blew its top – it’s depressing being there because it’d dead) and there’s a whole thing about God, and how much Tricia’s dad wants to do God, and all that stuff. And then her dad has a few bad attacks of coughing, and they go to the ER a few times.

And then it’s the day of the big race, and Tricia hangs around helping take care of her horse when she by rights should be in the jockey’s room (which by the way, she never did take her jockey test apparently – you’d think it would have been big news) and she finally goes to get changed. But then she leaves the room, and hooks up with Brad before she weighs in. Now see, right here, I’m convinced that Lauraine Snelling knows jackshit about horse racing. That just would not happen. Ever. And then her ChampionSpecialSuperWonderHorse goes right to the lead, and runs and runs without her ever ever having to whip him, but then a horse comes from behind them, and the mean bad jockey is whipping his horse (clearly this other horse doesn’t run for love of the girl alone!) and there’s a photo finish, but Tricia wins, and everyone is happy. Even Mumsy because she gets to stand in the winner’s circle. Bully. Personally, I think everyone made a big fuss over a maiden win. I mean, honestly, every other horse was brand-spanking new to racing too. It’s not like Spitfire beat Ghostzapper, Big Brown, Secretariat and Smarty Jones.

Ye Olde Points of Interest
  • The farm Tricia grew up on is called Runnin’ On Farm, and they have a three-quarter mile track. Now, this makes sense. A farm with a mile-long track is stupid, and insane, no matter how rich or big time the farm is. Ever seen photos of Churchill Downs from the blimp? It’s freaking huge. Think of the property taxes a farm would have to pay to have enough land for that!
  • The old gray Napolean-wannabe is named Dan’l. Now, I don’t get some of the pretentious names that racehorses are often given, but what the effing hell is a name like Dan’l?
  • Tricia’s best friend, Rhonda, supposedly rides gaited horses. And then later in the book, she’s going to a jumping competition. Idiot! Gaited horses is not like riding jumpers. Get your disciplines right, Mrs. Snelling!
And thus ends my review of The Race. I certainly have no intention of going back to read any of the others, made easier by the fact that I don’t have any of the other books. End of story. I guess it’s time to go torture myself with crazy stallions, and lost foals. Ugh!

Jun 15, 2008

Irish Hearts by Nora Roberts (Irish Rose)

Irish Hearts (Irish Rose)
by Nora Roberts

I think I've finally completed my trek through horsey Nora Roberts novels, unless I'm sorely mistaken and I really hope I'm not because if I have to read about one more male hero with a strange addiction to cigars I am going to fly off the handle.

Anyway.

Yeah, I just thought I'd throw in another version of the cover for extra kicks and...well, it's boring so I don't know why I bothered. Three horses (one of them looks suspiciously like a cow), fence, giant house, landscape that I assume is Maryland, etc. It's all inferior to Nora Roberts' name, which should tell you something.

Erin McKinnon. A bold beauty, she accepted Burke Logan's loveless proposal and his cool promise of security and wealth. But could this ravishing Irish Rose win her hard-hearted husband's love?
Okay, so I waded through the last half of this book and finally broke down and skimmed the last quarter or so, and now I will regurgitate it to the best of my ability. The first thing you have to ask yourself after reading the above blurb is: why are they married in the first place? This is 1988. Surely this isn't some strange Irish mail order bride arrangement, right? Well, no. No it is not. Allow me to explain.

The first thing you need to know is that according to Nora Roberts, every Irish woman who arrives in America during the 1980s has no idea what electricity is. Basically. Like...dishes are washed by hand and pencil sharpeners have cranks and being a wife means you can wash the floor if you damn well feel like it because you own the floor. These are the kind of women we're dealing with here.

Erin is Adelia's...well, Adelia and Erin's mothers were third cousins so does that make them fourth cousins or third cousins once removed? However that works, they're barely related but they are Irish and therefore this relation is enough to basically make them sisters. Erin still lives in the old country and Adelia has been married for seven years and I was so hoping someone would compare her to a broodmare because she's had three kids at this point and is pregnant with twins. Unfortunately for me comparisons to horses wait until the end of the book, and only then in a somewhat unoffensive way. Anyway. Adelia and Travis and their hoard of children arrive in Ireland with Burke Logan (their neighbor, so why he's there is never really explained other than he has to be for the story to work). Burke Logan is one of those roguishly handsome types who's all "if I wanted to kiss you I would have done it already" and spends all his time staring at people in an attractive and yet completely frustrating way. Erin is the girl who gains his attention, and she doesn't want to be stared at but really she does and who knows how this eventually works out because I can't even begin to explain it because this logic doesn't really work in the real world.

Burke and Erin enter into this weird lust/hate relationship, culminated in him offering her a job as his bookkeeper because she hates living in Ireland and he sort of wants her but not really. Or, at least, not yet. So they get caught in the rain one day in Ireland and he casually offers her the job and she tries to kill him with a rake, only of course her empowered attempt to slice him to ribbons is dismantled by his masculine coolness. He disarms her and slams her into a wall and that's all sexy, I guess, and he offers her the job that she accepts and then he tries to not have sex with her in the shed in the rain and all that jazz.

SO. Erin trots off to America and lives with her third cousin once removed and works for Burke. Eventually it becomes obvious that the two just don't get along, along with the fact that they just really want to rip at each other's clothes whenever they're not getting along, which is all the time. He essentially wants her to be his live in lover, which is totally not going to fly with Erin, and so she goes off and flirts with someone else and he gets all pissed off and drags her off to his house (again, which is apparently sexy) and manhandles her (again, supposedly sexy) and has the appropriately glossed over sex (which, ding!, deflowers her and totally was not expected but of course was). So he's all oh, she was "innocent" and she's all "stop babying me even though I'm curled up in the fetal position and not responding to you" and he babies her anyway and eventually decides they should get married. She goes along with this for some reason and thus they are married.

Afterward Erin's all put off because he doesn't want her to act like a wife. For clarification, being a wife to Erin means she should make her husband breakfast, make the bed, and clean things. To Burke, he just wants her to do whatever she wants so long as she doesn't clean anything. You can imagine the disconnect, and I'm not really sure who is more annoying here. Erin takes this to mean she's just a legal mistress. Burke takes this to mean she's crazy. I think it's a little bit of both. Anyway, we soon discover all of Burke's stupid hardships because his daddy abandoned his mommy and left him with this really random half-Latino half-sister named Rosa that he has clean his house while refusing to acknowledge her as his sister. That...is weird, to say the least. So Erin finally starts breaking things and informing him that she will not be cleaning up after herself and all is just dandy in the Logan household.

Until the Bluegrass Stakes, which again Nora Roberts seems to genuinely think takes place at Churchill Downs. Burke's horse, Double Bluff (because he is a gambler and thus all things associated with him must be named after gambling terms, if he isn't thinking in gambling terms...all this crap about folding hands and falling chips and odds making...the farm is called Three Aces. I mean, couldn't it have just ended there?), runs in the Bluegrass Stakes and is disqualified immediately after he finishes because he's been drugged. Like...I don't get how that works, but whatever. He's drugged, they know instantaneously, and he's disqualified. Moving on to the Kentucky Derby, we discover that some previously affluent trainer had someone drug the horse and now wants to kill it on Derby day with cyanide. Because the Kentucky Derby is so uber shady and this happens all the time, right?

Erin is down in the backside trying to get herself over her fear of horses. This is at least a little refreshing. She's terrified of the things, but she's starting to get over it until she overhears the trainer and his accomplice talking about the drugging. They find her and toss her in a van and discuss killing her. Enter massive plot point that completely justifies how any completely doomed relationship eventually works out in fiction (even though it never makes sense, and usually happens in fan fiction most of the time): the girl is in danger, so the guy swoops in and saves her, therefore saving their strained and/or psychotic relationship! Burke does just this, after this completely inane conversation with a policeman who is trying to somehow decipher if Erin was kidnapped or just decided to rent a car and take a nice Saturday drive on Derby day. No kidding. Talk about incompetent.

So the accomplice fesses up and Burke finds Erin and he takes her home and treats her like china and won't have sex with her which is AGAIN massive end of the world. Then she goes to the hospital to be there for Adelia as she foals, or whatever people described as Thoroughbreds do when they give birth. She leaves a note for Burke, who finds the note and the little slip of paper that declares that Erin is pregnant. Convinced she's gone to the hospital to get an abortion he runs to the maternity ward (do they do abortions in maternity wards?) and discovers it's just Adelia giving birth to twin ponies or whatever. He again hauls Erin home (sexy! really!) and they get in a fight about this pregnancy business and he's all yeah, maybe I did actually only marry you because I wanted you as my mistress but you didn't want that but now I totally do love you. And she drops all her plans of leaving and going back to Ireland because he finally says he loves her and will now consider putting down roots finally because he's going to be a father. Thus the second plot point that justifies how every crazy and/or estranged relationship works out in fiction (and, as it would happen, the real world): pregnancy!

The only oddity I can remember:

  • Right where I started to skim the book, some previous library patron helpfully landmarked the end of this strange romance novel stint of mine by drawing what looked to be a penis across the page. Thank you, anonymous Pittsburgh library system patron! Sadly, that brightened this reading experience considerably.

Wow, that was depressing. Honestly, if you read True Betrayals, don't bother with this one because it's basically taking half of that novel and replacing it with some Irish girl who's worried she married for money.

I'm also just sticking this under the completely vague tag "other books" because I can't in good faith recommend this as it mainly depressed me and it's not related to Thoroughbred. But it wasn't so bad to be a book to avoid. Okay. I'm done here. The Thoroughbred by Joanna Campbell is up next.

(Related review: Irish Thoroughbred)

Oh, crap! Another Image book! TB #52: Perfect Challenge

Ok, so I hated this book, so this review is going to be as short as possible.

The Cover

This is a scene that didn't happen in the book and that instantly annoys me. Plus, Image is ugly. And Melanie looks like she's about to platz in a major way. I really am not seeing the function of the seriously over-the-top breastplate. I cannot wait until I am past these covers that look like they've been drawn by 12 year-old fangirls. Moving along...

The Synopsis

Melanie Graham knows Image is Triple Crown material. The problem is, the filly is too smart for her own good. She's difficult to train, hates to be stabled indoors, and fights with other horses. But if Melanie is going to run Image in the Kentucky Derby, the Preakness, and the Belmont, the filly is going to have to get over herself.

For practice, Melanie takes Image to Florida to run in an easy fillies-only race. But when Melanie gets to the track, she discovers that her father has entered Image in the prestigious Florida Derby instead. He badly needs the purse money to save his failing business and he truly believes Image can win. Melanie is doubtful. Will Image rise to the challenge?

Hey, at least this one is true. They had to get something right sometime, I suppose.

The Plot

Image: The stupid black filly is back! This time, 'Team Image' is in Florida, where Image was supposed to run in the Bonnie Miss. But, things ever go easily for the diva horse and she gets entered in the Florida derby instead, where she will have to run against colts... to make matters worse, Image first cannot stay at some farm they had arranged due to an outbreak in strangles. Then, she is such a bitch that she gets kicked out of her accomodation at the track. Having no choice, Mel et al decide to keep her at some random farm where Image befriends this pony, Baby. Baby quickly becomes more reason for her to act all anxious and throw tantrums. But, Mel trains her in a corn field, avoids nasty media attention and they eventually come second in the Florida Derby. Yeah, Image didn't win. Joy! At the end of this book, Will Graham sells out his share of Image to Jazz.

Melanie: Mel goes from doubt to non-doubt to doubt again so many times in this book, I finally understand how they made their page quota. At least Chris wasn't around for her to fight with. But, Alexis Huffman, the demon incarnate who used to manage Tall Oaks, is! It seems Alexis has nothing better to do with her time than make things hard for Mel and Image. So, she slanders the filly's name and spreads all sorts of runours, some of which are actually true, but anyway. Melanie gets all upset and blames Alexis for everything bad and wrong. She is also pissed at her father for entering Image in the Florida Derby but this is quickly forgotten becuase we ALL KNOW the silly filly can win the race against colts. Duh. Mel is also dealing with her feelings for Jazz, who is just so good looking, anyone with hormones falls at his feet. Jazz and Mel kiss... in what must be one of the more racy TB kisses in history... Mel decides to get over him being Image's full owner... 'cause they're really partners now. All is fine and Mel sets her hopes on Triple Crown glory.

Will: Well, his business isn't doing so hot after he invested in a band called Bugg Spray. Now, if it were me, that name would have been indication enough. Anyway, Will needs some cash quick and he enters Image in the Florida Derby. He runs around for the rest of the book, whining about money, making stupid comments about Image and wearing floral shirts.

Joe: Has a family! Who visit him in Florida. Who knew?

Jazz: Must die. I want to chop off his dumb ponytail and tell him to stop running around like a younger Steven Segal.

There are no interesting points in this book. Other than the red colouring of the spine reminds me of candy apples and there is an outdated competition that I was too old to enter even at the time of publication... not that I am a US citizen anyway.

If you think the review sucks, read the book. I dare you. Your eyes will bleed. I think my next one is Great Expectations, which not a very appropriate title, as I have none.

Jun 14, 2008

Chris and Star Tour California! TB 51: Distance Runner

Ok, so I now have the time to kill and a hefty pile of select TB books next to my bed. Kind of like some 14 year-old's stash of porn...

I give you the review of Distance Runner, in which Jennifer Chu introduces some pointless characters and Chris and Star escape the pressures of Mel's bitchiness and get to do some touring on the side.

The Cover

I really hate this phase of covers from book 43-57... Star's mouth looks like his lips have been fused together and Christina is wearing Steve Urkel glasses. Her silks are also the wrong colours! Well, at least the saddle has a girth and stirrups and Christina is not wearing cowboy boots or a scarf...

The Synopsis

Christina and Star need a change of pace.
A competitive bug is sweeping through Whitebrook Farm. Image, Star, and Gratis are all contenders for the Triple Crown races, which begins with the Kentucky Derby, a little over a month away.

Christina can't stand the pressure. So, when she is given the chance to leave Kentucky for a little while and ride for another farm in California, where Derby fever isn't quite as intense, she packs her bags and takes Star with her. There, Chris focuses on making the most of Star's running style. He's always been a come–from behind–horse, but he sometimes misses his chance to beat the leaders. Christina is going to try to change that in time for the Derby. But it may not be as easy as she thinks.

The Plot

So, Christina is getting excited for the Kentucky Derby, but she is having problems as per usual with Star. Star isn't running flat out in his workouts, which is apparently a bad thing as that's what super-talented race horses have to do all the time. They are at Keeneland, prepping for the Blue Grass.

While Chris is wandering around the backside, she sees this insane horse fighting against one of those hotwalker machines. The horse is all tangled in his lead and Chris sets him free, a selfless act which will surely be the start of some miracle bond with this new nutjob. The horse's owners, the Johnstons, rush up, apprently remembering that they have left their expensive racehorse alone with a piece of machinery. Chris lands with her bum in the butter and get's to ride this new horse, Callie, in a race that afternoon.

Mel just happens to be riding Raven in the same race. Chris does, as per usual, a good job with Callie and wins the race but Mel lodges a protest against her in a bitchy attempt to change the results. The protest does not stand and Chris poses with Callie and the Johnstons are so thrilled that they want Chris to retrain Callie-poo in... gasp... California!

Ashleigh and Mike of course are against the idea.

Chris and Mel go to Katie's eighteenth birthday party. Normally, they would be indulging in some more adult activities at such a thing, but this is Thoroughbred. So it does not get any more interesting than gossiping in a hot tub and watching Indiana Jones. During the party, things are tense between our favorite cousins. It seems Mel can only be a nice person in her own books.

When the girls arrive back, Parker clearly had fuck-all to do but mope around the mare's paddock in the middle of the night. He and Chris break up, to save themselves more hurt, or whatever. I personally think Parker is sleeping with Kaitlin at this point, as she is not a main character and can be engaged in sexual activities. It actually has nothing to do with him going to England to train for Burghley. Parker is a man! He needs more than chaste kisses on the cheek!

Blah blah blah... Star is still not running full-out and Chris refuses to use a whip to beat some speed into him. She decides that a change of scenery is the way to go! Not that she and Star didn't go to Montana and then New Orleans or whatever... but help comes in the form of Cindy, who is in an unusually chipper mood due to her enlivened sex life with Ben. Cindy reminds Ashleigh that competition can be nasty between family and they all agree that Chris and Star can jetset off to Cali and run in the Santa Anita Derby! Yay!

Chris arrives in Cali and swoons over Dreamflight and their pretty facilities. Oh, and Aaron. Who just happens to be uber cute and focused on horses! Aaron gets chucked off this colt, Blue Streak Christina just leaps on the colt in her nice jeans and without a helmet rides him well.... as per freaking usual!

More drama over Star and his shitty fractions... Chris still refuses to use a crop, giving her horse far too much credit in the smarts department. Aaron offers to take Chris to Universal Studios, where he will have to chance to grope her in one of the dark rides. Chris is so upset over Star, she refuses, not at all aware of Aaron's intentions.

Callie and Star would make the perfect horse if they were moulded together. All Callie wants to do is run and could show Star a thing or two, or so Chris thinks. But she has to prove that she made the right choice (sound familiar?)

After much discontent with both Star and Callie sucking, Chris cries like a baby and Aaron comforts her and she basks in his warm manliness. They go touring around LA and Christina has the miraculous epiphany that she just needs to let Star and Callie do their thing without trying to change their style of running. Wow.

So Chris and Aaron ride Star and Callie together that evening without permission and both horses seem all fine and dandy now. The next day, Chris breezes Callie and the Johnstons and the horse's owner are happy.

Callie runs his race, the San Philipe stakes and wins it wire to wire and then Chris wins again with Star. All is well again and we leave California with promises of dinner dates and more work that never really get met as these people don't exist outside of Jennifer Chu's books.

Points of Interest

  • Yeah, I bet people just randomly offer strangers to ride their horses in races that take place... like hours after they first meet them!
  • Mel is such a bitch. She should be fucking grateful that she even has Image to race and that her body is still intact.
  • Storm's Ransom gets an honorable mention. It seems the mere mention of his name still reduces Cindy into a blubbering wreck.
  • At least Jennifer has some knowledge of TB history. Unlike, oh, any of the other NewGen authors.
  • I find myself wishing that Aaron was in more books than just Jennifer Chu's. For the simple reason that he might have been less boring than Parker.
  • Chris asks Aaron which horses are going to Santa Antia and his reply is "pretty much anyone who is sound." Ding ding ding! Warning bells, anyone?
  • Does a theme park called California Adventure really exist?
  • What is is with TB characters riding their horses without permission?
  • Boy oh boy, I thought seventeen year olds were beyond crying when they do not get their way.
  • Jennifer Chu likes name dropping brands, famous actors and all that, doesn't she?

Well, this book was pointless... but not as pointless as the next one on my list... the aptly named Perfect Challenge!

Jun 13, 2008

Mel and Aynslee would totally tip cars together. TB #25: Melanie's Treasure

Melanie's Treasure
Thoroughbred #25
by Allison Estes
Published: 1998

It took me a while to get to reading this book, for reasons I can't explain. Well, here it is:

Melanie reminds me of someone...I just can't put my finger on it. Anyway, it's a good cover. It even makes sense in a general proportion sort of way, so we'll continue on.
She's his last hope...

Ever since 13-year-old Melanie Graham was sent to live with her aunt Ashleigh and uncle Mike at Whitebrook Farm, she's struggled for a way to fit in. Everything she does is wrong. She doesn't get along with her cousin Christina and riding racehorces is nothing like riding back in New York.

Then she sees Pirate's Treasure. The powerful black stallion has incredible potential. But he's also unpredictable--and dangerous. Then he's retired from his racing career and turned out to pasture. Soon he begins to lose his will to live. Can Melanie break through Pirate's distrust and prove to everyone he has the heart of a champion?
The beginning of this book is basically witnessing Melanie dabble with her budding life of crime as she's quickly led onto a path that will most certainly land her in juvy. It all starts innocently enough...Melanie wants to go on a romantic moonlit ride with her best friend, Aynslee. For some reason this is just going to be beyond fun, because they can go off the bridle paths at night and no one can stop them! Except for, you know, the police. Best to just not think about that, and Melanie certainly doesn't.

Fresh from dying her hair with Kool-Aid (probably just like this), she clues Aynslee in on her plan. Aynslee is the type that tends to take other people's ideas and exaggerates them to beyond manageable proportions, so by the time Melanie gets rid of her father and gets to the stable, Aynslee has already thought of a) to bribe the night watchman with pizza, b) to drug the night watchman's dog so they can more easily get in and out of the stable and c) that if Melanie tries to back out of their plan she will tell everyone and get Melanie in so much trouble she will have wished she'd never met Aynslee to begin with. Basically, Melanie is screwed. She just doesn't know it yet.

They go out on their ride, which was just begging to end in disaster. This comes to fruition when the police find them trying to run the bases with their horses at one of the park's baseball diamonds. Aynslee's first reaction? Run. Melanie's first reaction? Stare, before casually letting her horse bolt off after Aynslee. Melanie clearly isn't a natural at this juvenile delinquent thing, but she does manage to outrun the police three wheelers before both horses walk onto a metal plate, which is their undoing. Milky Way starts to slip and thrash around, tosses Melanie, who dislocates her shoulder, and then one of those typical rabid cab drivers flies around the corner of the street and careens straight into Milky Way. You can imagine the trauma that caused, not to mention that Aynslee decides to pin the entire thing on Melanie, which is okay because it's all mainly Melanie's fault anyway.

Instead of facing legal ramifications, Melanie is sent off to live with Ashleigh and Mike at Whitebrook, because Will Graham decides that Melanie just hasn't been happy living in New York, thereby leading her to her hardened life of coloring her hair with Kool-Aid and stealing all the chalk in her teacher's class room. Melanie, just in case we weren't aware, is a NEW YORKER, and thus does not understand how anyone can live in areas with vast tracts of vegetation. So she decides to be as surly and ungrateful as possible when she lands in Louisville. She does take some time to nurse her remarkably low self-esteem by wishing she'd been able to dye her hair green, because she is oh-so-sure that these Louisville hicks would be so shocked and bothered by green hair. She also decides not to get involved with another horse, or ride another horse, as part of her guilt over accidentally squishing Milky Way with a cab.

The next morning she meets our dashing main horse, Pirate's Treasure. The horse gets away from Ian and does a bee line straight to Melanie, who won't get out of the way no matter how often Kevin tells her to move. Instead she just does her staring thing and the horse comes to a natural stop in front of her, which Melanie totally expected because she's so cool.

Unfortunately, she is just so not cooler than Christina, and Melanie's envy of her cousin is pretty obvious because Christina has a horse and actually knows what she's talking about and Melanie killed the horse she was going to lease and hardly comprehends eventing. Therefore, in the riding school hierarchy, Christina is on top and can afford to push Melanie, who is lowest on the totem pole, all over the place without caring about her feelings. This also means that Melanie can't touch Sterling Dream, which results in a screaming fit because Christina is absolutely certain her horse doesn't like strangers touching her. AT ALL. You'd think all that shrieking and flailing would upset the mare more than Melanie touching her nose, but Christina is on the top of the hierarchy, and therefore it doesn't. Plus, Sterling would never bite Christina. Because she is a horse riding goddess.

However! Melanie is not to be discounted! After nearly being trampled by The Terminator, she pulls herself together and stomps back to the training oval, where Ian has been trying to get Pirate to load into the training gate. She offers to lead the horse in, and it all clicks into place. Melanie has potential to be a horse riding goddess also when Pirate inexplicably follows Melanie right into the gate. So Melanie is now Pirate's special person, and they have a bond that can never be broken. Christina is not so sure of this, especially after Pirate breaks free of his cross ties and is practically magnetically attracted to Sterling. Sterling must be pretty sexy, because Pirate goes through quite a lot trying to get to her so he can superficially injure the mare's shoulder. Sterling gets a little cut on her shoulder and Ian remarks that it will need a stitch or two, which Christina practically starts to weep over like the horse riding goddess she is. Sterling's superficial pain is Christina's superficial pain! Or something.

Horrified, Melanie runs up to the house and calls her father, who tells her to basically grow up and no, she will not be coming to Europe with him, and then Aynslee, who tells her that their relationship is basically over. Shocked and appalled, Melanie decides she'll never get out of this summer alive! Or, she will have to spend the entire summer being everyone else's scapegoat as she complains and whines about everything.

Ian seems to know Melanie is out of sorts, so he tells her he needs her to act as Pirate's groom for a while. During this time Pirate freaks out during a work out and nearly kills Anna Simms when he bucks across the finish line at Whitebrook's training oval. Then Melanie has her great Cindyesque moment of enlightenment! Pirate is afraid of shadows. Yay. Congrats, Mel. Score one for your fragile self-esteem and let's move on, because Ashleigh's feeling all soft-hearted again and before we know it she's offering Mel one of their yearlings. Which Melanie is totally not happy about because she's not riding horses anymore. Doesn't anyone ever listen to her crazy ranting?

Then the real reason comes out. Ashleigh thinks Pirate is too much horse for her to handle, which now Mike totally agrees with despite them both saying it was a fantastically great idea practically three days ago. My how we change our minds in this series. So Melanie is all offended and insists on working with only Pirate while Christina accuses her of being a horse killer, while Melanie takes some time to realize that ohmigod, that's actually true!

So she's all depressed and Mike tricks her into going to Keeneland to watch Pirate race, where he wins and then crashes into another horse and creates another opportunity for Melanie to cry. Pirate is gelded and stitched up and tossed in a paddock, where he grows increasingly depressed. Mel and Chris bond a little bit in the attic as Chris convinces Melanie she is not bad luck for horses, and Melanie decides to ride Pirate around for a while because that's when he perks up. Then they stumble over a log while she's riding him and Melanie discovers that he's blind. Which would explain why he's been acting all batty for the majority of the book. Why no one else figured that out...well, you know. This is Thoroughbred. We know how this works by now.

We end with Melanie finally feeling like part of the family, and Pirate is now basically hers.

Oddities:

  • Melanie and Aynslee glue shut the outside doors of their private school. I don't know what kind of glue they're using here, but it must be super industrial strength.
  • Compared to Whitebrook's sleek thoroughbreds, all of the stable horses in New York are basically grotesque horse-like mutants.
  • You would think Melanie wouldn't need someone to tell her that Pirate's Treasure is a thoroughbred, since she knew in advance that Whitebrook was a thoroughbred training farm. Kevin clearly thinks she's an idiot and says very clearly (and probably slowly, so as she can understand his big, technical words): "Whitebrook is a thoroughbred training facility."
  • Naomi informs us all that she is an apprentice jockey, which lasts until she gets her first win. Which is so glaringly wrong.
The Rule (because I know this pops up again, and it's wrong every other time as well): An apprentice jockey shall be allowed the following weight allowances in all Thoroughbred, Appaloosa, Arabian and Paint races: (a) Ten pound allowance beginning with the first mount and continuing until the apprentice has ridden five winners. (b) A seven pound allowance until the apprentice has ridden an additional 35 winners; and (c) If an apprentice has ridden a total of 40 winners prior to the end of a period of one year from the date of riding their fifth winner, they shall have an allowance of five pounds until the end of that year. (d) If after one year from the date of his or her fifth winning mount the apprentice has not ridden 40 winners, the applicable weight allowance shall continue for one more year or until the date of the 40th winner, whichever comes first.
  • Christina tells Melanie not to go to the stallion barn, since the horses are aggressive and Mr. Ballard hates people. Melanie goes there anyway, gets to know Blues King, and then stupidly walks into The Terminator's stall. When the horse tries to trample her she escapes easily enough, only to run into Mike. So she whips up some tears because "she's from New York City. They wouldn't expect her to know much about horses." Clearly, she doesn't know much about horses. This is blatantly obvious. She could just own up to this fact and save me some eye rolling.
  • Is the horse called Pirate Treasure or Pirate's Treasure?
  • Pirate wins two races with only a week in between, so I am now convinced that Allison really doesn't understand that racehorses are not, in fact, (E)venters.
  • Keeneland Race Track is actually Keeneland Race Course. Because they're all stuffy and inclined to pretend they're European there.
So. Yeah. That is Melanie's Treasure. Want some more? Monique's review is here.