Sep 10, 2008

Dead Heat: Because it's more fun if we could all be winners.

Dead Heat
Thoroughbred #35
by Alice Leonhardt
Published: 1999

Um. So here's this book:

I believe Claire pointed out the silk blouses on this cover, and I'd just like to echo that observation. Because, seriously, what's going on here? On top of which, shouldn't they look like they're blowing around in the breeze, given how loose they are? Other than that, this is a scene from the book, which I don't know why I bother to point his out because it's not like it matters.

Galloping head to head...

Melanie Graham is thrilled. She loves exercise riding, and she's good at it, too! Her aunt Ashleigh says Melanie would make a great jockey - she's really thriving at Whitebrook.

But Melanie's not alone. Her friend Kevin McLean also wants to exercise-ride, and soon Melanie an Kevin are galloping together on the Whitebrook track. Racing for fun turns serious as Melanie becomes more and more competitive, testing their friendship to the limit. Kevin thinks Melanie is pushing herself too hard. Will she slow down before it's too late?
One thing I had a hard time with during this book was the complete spasticness (if that's not a word, it is now) of the plot. Sure, there is a bit of a rivalry between Kevin and Melanie, but it's not like that was going anywhere, and half the time Melanie seemed pretty confused about it. This equaled extreme boredom on my part, which is why it's taken me so long to get around to posting this review. It actually took me over a week to wander my way through this book, much to my shame. Although I imagine it's going to be worse for me when I go through Ashleigh's Hope. Just looking at that book makes me sigh.

Well, moving on. Melanie wants to be a jockey, so she's daydreaming about winning the Kentucky Derby all the time and is falling back on her school work. Everyone knows this is what she's doing, but no one really seems to care enough to smack her, tell her she's thirteen, and really she can eat like a normal teenager because she isn't jockeying anything for three years. Seriously, kid, you can live on more than half an English muffin and a tablespoon of yogurt right now. But because Naomi has scared Melanie into believing that she has to start exercising and ruining her body now instead of three years from now, Melanie is taking her anorexic spin seriously. People sort of notice, but yeah, no one really holds an intervention or anything. They just let her continue on, sucking at school and trying desperately to fit into the Cindy mold, which is proof positive, again, that Ashleigh is a horrible guardian. How Christina turned out relatively balanced in all the Melanie books is anyone's guess (of course, this is followed by Christina being a relative pain in the ass in all of her books, so it's a toss up, really. Maybe Ashleigh just sucks at being a parent in general.)

Lately, Kevin has been being a jerk for mysterious reasons. Again, no one really notices or acts like it's a big deal besides Melanie, who reacts by trying to one up Kevin in their exercising horses and trying to groom the special horses and what all. Samantha and Ian buy this Wind Chaser horse, who is god in the form of a horse, and Melanie and Kevin compete to be the horse's groom (Where are the god damned grooms at Whitebrook?), and Melanie gets the job seemingly randomly (well, totally randomly) and Kevin is further pissy.

Melanie continues to suck at school, and she gets her mid term grades only to discover she's failing two classes. She manages to side step Ashleigh easily enough for a day or two, but eventually Ashleigh acts smart finally and calls the school, resulting in learning the grades and forcing Melanie to call her father, who does as much long distance parenting as he can to make up for Ashleigh's huge amount of tremendous fail. Ashleigh and Will come up with a contract that will force Melanie to realize she needs a life outside of the farm and trying to be a jockey before she can actually be a jockey. You'd think Ashleigh would have seen the signs of Melanie pulling a Cindy, but not so much. Melanie grudgingly accepts the contract and accepts the fact that she's going to be forced to attend this camp out with her friends. God, who wants to deal with friends on a consistent basis? It would be so much better to just sit and mope in the barn without human companionship.

So she's forced to go on the camping trip and eventually everyone gets stuck in the woods somewhere and Melanie has to save the day with Kevin, forcing the two to come to terms with their completely random problems. Turns out Kevin is annoyed that Melanie traded in her fun personality with the moping personality of a completely uninteresting middle aged woman, and Kevin is not attracted to that. And he was kind of pissed off that his dad bought Wind Chaser the wonder horse without his say (like...uh, what? Kevin, you're twelve. What reasonable adult consults their twelve-year-old son on a multi million dollar racing prospect? If you're not the Townsends, I should say?). And he was annoyed that Melanie was being all uppity and competitive. And this is why he's dating Heather now. So Melanie and Kevin are back to being friends and Melanie learns that interpersonal relationships are more important than sitting around moping in a barn with no one to talk to.

  • This is basically Arabian Challenge rewritten for Melanie. Melanie wants to be a jockey, she spends too much time with horses and not enough time realizing she's only 13, her friendships suffer, Melanie acts like a brat, and then the message is rammed home in the end. Only there is a message in this book. There was no message in Arabian Challenge that wasn't friends and winning are important. You can have your cake and eat it too! That, at least, doesn't happen here.
  • Stoney/Stone is sold. Random, but appreciated. I'll give Alice that.
  • Alice spends a lot of time on damage control from On the Track. You can just tell. She has to explain the foal that Lois shoved in there, saying there is no way this foal is going to have a logical career (well, basically) because she was an unfortunate fall foal. I just got a kick out of that.
  • Seriously, Ian empties his savings to buy this Wind Chaser with Samantha? Tor and Beth both thought it was a bad idea, so this seems forced to the point of ridiculousness.
  • Mr. Wonderful gets a shout out because Wind Chaser looks just like him. Alice calls Mr. Wonderful the best sire at Whitebrook Farm, only she gets him completely confused with Wonder's Pride. I appreciate that Alice names Mr. Wonderful as the best sire at the farm, because I can really see that happening. However, she's confusing the two mainly because Wind Chaser has the flaxen mane, just like Mr. Wonderful. Pride was just a boring old chestnut. Sorry, Alice.
  • I am convinced now that Kevin and Melanie had no real relationship. Which is fine with me because they are way too young to be taking this junk that seriously.
  • Ashleigh sucks so hard at being a guardian. Really. She's a complete push over. Not doing well in school? Don't worry, Ashleigh was bad too! Doing something completely unrealistic with your horse? Don't worry, Ashleigh bucked tradition too! And Ashleigh takes this like a punch to the face every time.
  • I also find it incredibly annoying that no matter what Ashleigh dresses in she always looks like "a little kid." This just disturbs me in general. 36 isn't old, but is isn't 12 either. I don't care if she's wearing a headband, a baseball hat, or lace underwear, okay? It's just creepy.
But, yeah, this was a pretty dull installment. In fact, I'm going to stop here and refer everyone back to Claire's review. Next I'm going to gather up a few of these requests and take a stab at some of those. If this means I have to read about the Irish...well, that's what I'll do. Cheers!

Caitlin's Way: Bears are cuddly and harmless! Don't listen to the experts!

Season 1, Episode 8: Bear With Me
Aired: 4/9/2000

If you're at all curious, the title is, in fact, literal. There is a bear on the loose in High River, the Montana town Caitlin lives in. Look at me, picking up on facts! So the show opens up with Caitlin running into a Grizzly that's rummaging through some trash. As it turns out, the bear has escaped from a zoo (which would then imply that there is a zoo somewhere near this podunk town, which I tend to doubt in general) and Jim, as the sheriff, needs to catch it. Enter Caitlin to screw this plan up. Wild things should not be in cages! Shock of all shocks, Caitlin does not believe in zoos or keeping animals captive, unless they're wild horses that "choose" to stay with their human masters by being kept in pastures and stalls and given no chance to be free, when they would actually be able to choose, and if there is ever a point where they get loose, they're hunted down and returned to their stall. If that's choosing, Caitlin needs to hunt down a dictionary.

Nevertheless, Bandit chose to stay with Caitlin! (Except for that one time when he got loose and she had to catch him, which was totally just him working out, like, restlessness or something, and not him wanting to be free again. Sure.) But the bear is wild and therefore must totally want to be wild! Despite being in captivity his whole life and probably having no clue what the hell he's doing outside in the "real world"! Not to even mention that whole danger to humans issue. Caitlin ain't touching that.

So, everyone else thinks Caitlin is being completely unreasonable about this. Also, Jim is up for re-election and he actually has competition this year, giving Griffen fits over whether or not his dad will have a job come...whenever the term is up and everyone votes again. The competition is Eric's dad, so the two boys get into this campaign war that I am going to ignore.

Meanwhile, Dori sets up a bear trap. It's one of those tin can things with a trap door, which is completely safe, but she has to show Caitlin how it works so Caitlin can be pacified and learn how to sabotage it later. Which she does. Then she rides Bandit out in the woods and happens across the bear. Bandit, being smart, high tails it out of there. Caitlin, being an idiot, stays and gives the bear food. And she sits there within striking distance and takes its picture.

Does anyone remember Grizzly Man? About the crazy guy who lived as close to bears as possible and was very possibly deranged and then he got eaten? That was all I could really think of while I was watching this. She's giving a most probably starving bear food and then she sits there like the main course on the bear's menu. You can not be stupider. But, of course, the bear doesn't try to kill Caitlin. In fact, she makes this a regular part of her routine. Ride the horse, be bitchy, feed the wild/not wild starving bear, be bitchy some more...it's all in due course for Caitlin.

Until the bear finds the food Griffen has been preparing for his dad's annual barbecue and has a field day in their back yard. Griffen finds the bear and nearly gets his face ripped off, which finally makes Caitlin come clean about all she's been doing regarding the bear. She takes them out into the forest and shows them what she's been up to. The bear freaking comes when called and the zoo handler puts a chain around the bears neck and walks it, like it's a dog, back to wherever they came from. I really have no words.

Jim wins reelection and the bear doesn't go back to the zoo, but to a refuge. It's suggested that this was their doing, which I highly doubt because they don't own the damn bear. But whatever. Everyone is happy and they go out to eat because Jim still has a job. Yay!

Sep 9, 2008

Caitlin's Way: Veterinary science is no match for love.

Season 1, Episode 22: Under Western Skies
Aired: 9/3/2000

"Winter. When I lived in the city, I didn't think about it very much. That's 'cause it wasn't much fun. This is my first winter with Bandit. Being with him makes everything special. I guess if you love something, it doesn't matter where you are."

Too true, Caitlin. It is winter. And Caitlin is having fun despite this because she loves Bandit, which means that if she were to lose Bandit, winter would really suck. That's the first issue in this episode. The second is about Griffen trying to get on the junior hockey team, which seems difficult for him despite the fact that Jim is the coach. Also, he's upset that girls are allowed on the team this year. This is like sacrilege to Griffen, who holds fast to his belief that girls and boys should not play hockey together. His friend (who I've been calling "other guy," but actually has a name, which is Brett), just likes to watch them because girls in shoulder pads are hot. To him. This whole episode doesn't do Griffen any favors, I should just say now.

So Caitlin goes on a ride with Bandit so she can take pictures. While she's taking pictures, she allows Bandit to wander around the area by himself, which obviously wasn't a good idea because he walks right into one of those claw trap things. Caitlin runs off to get Dori, who is a vet and can supposedly help. She takes the claw trap off and move Bandit to the barn. Caitlin acts like a brat, Bandit goes into shock and his heart stops, but Dori gets it going again with an adrenaline shot.

On Griffen's end, he sucks at hockey. His prissiness isn't suited to brutal team sports, and this is emphasized by the fact that Blond Girl (actually, her name is Taylor) rams into him and his dad calls it fair play and wow, it sucks to be Griffen. He's chosen to be an alternate while Blond Girl gets on the team, equaling lots of father-son bickering. They come home to the drama with Bandit, which inevitably leads to Caitlin being a huge bitch to Dori because Dori's decisions might not have been the right ones and it's all Dori's fault! Yeah, she might as well have been the one that let the horse wander around an area she didn't really know that well! Screw her and her veterinary skills!

So Caitlin and Griffen sit in the barn and talk about love coming from the heart and they get all mushy. Then Caitlin and Dori sleep in the stall. And then Bandit is magically better the next day and Caitlin gives Dori this photography project she was working on as thanks. And Griffen and Jim practice hockey because Griffen still sucks at hockey. And Caitlin swallows her bitchiness and goes to help Dori with something. The End.

  • Who hates it when someone, like a vet, says that an injured horse might strike out and the Special Girl protests vehemently about how her Special Super Horse would never hurt her?
  • This episode was boring.
  • That is all.

Sep 7, 2008

Rich people have problems too.

Chance Meeting
by Laura Moore

Here is another romance novel. What can I say? Dead Heat is next.

Growing up trapped by her father's wealth, awkward Ty Stannard found freedom on horseback. A talented equestrian, she yearned to ride as well as her idol, champion Steve Sheppard. Worshiping the handsome Kentuckian, she treasures the lucky medallion he gives her the day they chance to meet. But then a nasty fall changes everything, and Ty is forced to leave her dreams behind.

Now a beautiful woman, determined to live life on her own terms, Ty learns that Steve stands on the brink of ruin. Moved by memories of his kindness to her, she offers him financial backing, but Steve perceives only a selfish socialite amusing herself at his expense. In a daring move, he challenges Ty to be not only a financial partner -- but a full-time farmhand as well, expecting she'll tire of the hardships of a working stable. To Steve's surprise, Ty takes up his challenge.

As they rebuild Southwind, Steve's beloved stable, they find unexpected strength and comfort in each other -- and a passion neither can deny. But their fragile love will be tested by not only those who seek to destroy what they have built, but also the insecurities and doubts that shadow their own very vulnerable hearts.
My library copy of this book makes it look like the guy is having a romantic chance meeting with a K-Mart promotional sticker, as that's what's covering up the girl and horse. As it is, this book takes place on Long Island, not Kentucky, so that accounts for the beach scene. I don't know what they're actually doing. Do romance novel covers usually make any sense anyway? That's a resounding no, so we'll move on.

So, it's 1989. Ty Stannard is a billionaire's daughter and Lizzie is her best friend. They are fourteen and in love with Steve Sheppard, who is 23 and a super fantastic rider. Ty has been hoarding pictures of him in her room for years, and so on. It's one of those big, completely hopeless crushes the less well known harbor on the more well known so the more well known can whine and bitch about it while secretly loving it. You know they do. Anyway, Ty and Lizzie are at a show in New York, and Steve is also there and Lizzie gets Ty to dump her bodyguard for a second so they can meet Steve. Which they do. And Steve gives Ty this medallion thing for good luck because he's supposed to be a nice guy, and then the bodyguard finds them and all hell breaks loose.

Ty has a bodyguard because her father, Tyler Stannard (who did, yes, name his daughter Tyler Maximilian Stannard after himself), is a billionaire and obsessed with the thought that someone might kidnap, rape, or otherwise accidentally touch Ty. So that's why she has Sam, the bodyguard. Sam is 29 at this point. I think that sets everything up. So we'll skip on to 1991, when Ty falls off her horse and her dad sells her horse because that damn horse can't be trusted. Sam quits in disgust. Steve buys a horse called Fancy Free. Okay, now we can move on to 1999.

Somewhere in the past eight years, Steve buys a farm on Long Island with this guy named Jason, who rapidly becomes a coke addict to the point that he manages to nearly bankrupt the farm. I don't know what kind of coke addiction you need in order to embezzle to the degree that you singlehandedly cause the ruination of a horse farm, but Jason manages it. More importantly, Steve somehow doesn't notice it, and then his horse, Fancy Free, gets his foot caught in a hay net and dies because Steve finds him when it was supposed to be Jason's night watching the stable, so he has to shoot Fancy. Then Steve beats the crap out of Jason, and seeing as how this is horse society and it's Long Island, the gossip starts raging full force soon after.

Enter Ty to magically save the day. She sells her Rolls Royce and her Lotis and her 5th Avenue apartment and offers to become 50/50 partners with Steve so Southwind will get back on its feet. It's important to note that they haven't seen each other since 1989 and they really don't know each other anyway, so I really didn't care about all this supposed history with the medallion that Ty keeps thinking about. Steve accepts the offer on some conditions, one among them being that Ty has to live on the farm so he can keep an eye on her. He does not trust partners after all, but really this is just a convenient excuse for them to have sex. Although they don't, really, have sex until later. This isn't a Karen Robards book, after all. If it was they'd be on the conference room table in front of the lawyers after fifteen minutes of knowing each other.

Well, anyway. Ty arrives at the farm and discovers the house is filthy. So she whips out her checkbook and has other people clean it. Good going, Ty. I was horrified for a moment that she was going to slip into traditional Disney heroine mode and clean it all herself. Steve is somewhat irked that she doesn't really skip a beat. He hates that she's there, but he's sort of lusting after her to a huge degree, and blah blah blah. Just make up something in your head and it probably happened.

Eventually, sick and tired of having him call her Junior to her face, Ty goes and buys some apple trees so she can plant them at Fancy's grave. This finally knocks sense into Steve's head. Instead of being a jerk, he can be grateful and nice and then maybe he'll finally get laid! Astonishing it took him this long to do that math. No wonder his farm failed and he never noticed his partner was that far gone. So they plant the apple trees and start making out.

Um...and then I guess I should mention that Ty's dad is doing his Evil Empire stuff back in Manhattan. He will convince Ty to come back to him and ruin Steve's life more than he's already ruined it himself and so forth. Back at the farm, Ty learns how to ride again but is so sore that she needs someone to walk on her back. And this results in the weirdest back-walking episode I have ever seen. Basically, Steve walks on her back and it's the most erotic back-walking EVER, which sort of disturbs me in general because I fail to see how this is possible. I don't care what he's doing to muscle groups or how he uses his toes, okay? It's ridiculous.

So then Lizzie shows up. Lizzie married the typical creep who became a creep the day she married him when he tried to rape Ty, who threw up on him. So Lizzie then got pregnant by him and then divorced him, so she's got this asshole ex-husband and a daughter, who is cute, named Emma. Lizzie shows up to help them with clients or some such. Then Sam shows up, so he can tell Ty what his government funded and therefore completely powerful and immune security business found out about her dad's financial maneuvering to screw up her life. And somewhere in there Sam decided he really wanted Lizzie, and Lizzie seems to have forgotten exactly how old Sam is (that would be 40) and mistakes him for 55. I don't know how. OH, it's PROBABLY BECAUSE SHE'S 25. Look, I can handle a ten year age difference. That is doable. When it gets up to 15, I start to get uncomfortable. Anyway, moving past my hang up on ages, I actually like Sam and Lizzie way more than Ty and Steve, mainly because Ty started to get pretty damn boring right about here. She's rich, she's a virgin, she's trying to be nice but keeps getting in stupid arguments with Steve that wind up with making out...it's pretty old at this point. Boo hoo, you're rich and a virgin. Have sex and shut up all ready.

But unfortunately not a whole lot happens that we see with Lizzie and Sam. I guess they verbally spar, which is far more interesting than Steve being upset when he finds out that Ty is that girl he gave the medallion to (like we care? what? this matters how?) before making out with her again. So Sam takes Lizzie home to Connecticut, where I guess they have sex off screen, and we are treated to Ty and Steve having sex, although they're really sappy about it and the phrase "make love" comes up way too much in its various formats. I hate the phrase "make love" mainly because it makes me cringe each time I see it. Sort of like the word slumber. Or the name Kevin. Or the name Steve for that matter. I hate the name Steve almost as much as I hate the name Kevin. I have no reasoning for these things, just in case you're curious.

So they have sex, but call it making love, and I give Laura tons of points for involving a condom that is actually used and not tossed to the side because Ty and Steve are too passionate for practicality. Only it's really awkward and comes across as a ten second sex ed course in the middle of all of it, which...very strange. I totally understand why most authors do away with that detail entirely. But, really, she's a virgin, Steve, not an idiot. I realize some people don't know how to put a condom on, but that's probably because they are idiots.

Well, they have sex and have their sentimental talk later about how they're so happy. I really wish the book ended there. But it doesn't. Instead they have to go compete, and I skimmed through that because I really didn't care. This girl named Cassie shows up, who I swear is a Mary Sue because I see no reasoning for her to be there at all other than to be perfect and nice and sell horses to people as she's busy being perfect and nice and perfect some more. Sam buys a horse for seemingly no reason, Ty and Steve have more sex, Lizzie and Sam verbally spar some more, which in its brevity still remains more interesting than Ty could ever hope to be, and then the Evil Empire rears its ugly head and tries to do something ineffective that causes some drama for five or six pages and then Steve tells off Ty's dad and then he proposes to Ty and asks her to have his amazing fantastical babies. The end.

That's it. No points of interest, really. Just another horsey romance novel over and done with.

Sep 6, 2008

Can you ever love something TOO much?

The Saddle Club #2: Horse Shy
Bonnie Bryant
Published: November 1988

The summary:

The three members of the Saddle Club -- Carole, Lisa, and Steve -- are the best of friends, bonded by their special love of horses. Now they're together on the long-awaited Mountain Trail Overnight, riding through the pine forests, swimming in mountain-water ponds, sharing a tent under the stars. ... They are having such a perfect time that nothing -- not even Veronica, the richest and snobbiest girl at the stables -- can spoil their fun.

But the impossible does happen. A tragic accident, caused by Veronica's carelessness, makes Carole lose the one thing she loved most in the world. Is her grief enough to make her give up riding forever?

The plot:

The book opens up with the Saddle Club out on a "practice" trail ride for MTO, since Lisa has only been riding for about three days. They manage to end up in absolutely the wrong field, where they come face to face with a bull. The only way to get out is to jump the fence, despite the fact that Lisa has been riding for about three days and Max doesn't allow his students to start jump classes for a year.

There are eleven people on the MTO: the Saddle Club (3), Veronica diAngelo, Meg Durham, Lorraine Olsen, Betsy Cavanaugh, Joe Novick, Adam Levine, Red O'Malley the stablehand, and of course Max himself. All of these kids seem to be about the age of the Saddle Club, which suggests that you have to be a certain age to go (clearly it has nothing to do with experience, since Lisa has been riding for about three days). We get some Quick Character Development on Mrs. Atwood (hovers, warns Lisa about things like "not going too close to the edge of the mountain"), Mrs. diAngelo (brings Veronica a set of expensive Hermes saddlebags and a bag of Perugina candies), and Carole (leaves her backpack and sleeping bag at home).

They drive up into some mountains and get this MTO started. They trot and canter. We learn that you should not give a hot horse a lot of water to drink at once. Carole and Red take care of Veronica's gorgeous stallion, Cobalt, when Veronica refuses to do it herself. They play horse games; make up stories about Max's grandfather, Maxmillian Regnery I, who founded Pine Hollow; try to get Max to tell them the real story about his grandfather; watch the deer grazing with horses; go swimming in mountain lakes; prance through rainbows, wear sparkly outfits, run from forest fires ... oh wait, wrong book. Anyway, it's kind of like Girl Scout camp on horseback, and really kind of sweet, even though Carole's horse, a palomino called Delilah, is being a bit of a cranky brat.

Except for the time that Max has all of the students, except Lisa-the-three-day rider of course, working on a small jump course, and Veronica gallops Cobalt up to a jump. Max rips her a new one for expecting Cobalt to "fling himself over a jump." Lisa has only been riding for three days, so she has no idea that this is a bad thing; she thinks Max was just looking for an excuse to yell at Veronica. Stevie sets her straight with a minimum of insults.

Back at PH, Carole exercises Cobalt. She loves this horse. He's a sweetheart and a beauty. Running fast and jumping high are in his bloodlines. Etc., etc. You can imagine how this is going to end.

Carole's dad has a business trip to North Carolina, so he takes Carole so she can spend some time with her mother's sister, Elaine, and her cousins, who are all young boys. Carole's mother was mentioned very briefly in the first book, as having died "six months earlier from cancer," but this one goes into a little more detail, especially about how hard Colonel Hanson finds it to be a single parent and Carole's willingness to reassure him that he is a terrific father. It's nicely done and not too anvilicious.

As soon as they get home, Stevie calls from PH, telling Carole to come immediately.

As they neared the stable, Carole could hear the terrible whine of a siren. An ambulance pulled out of the driveway and turned toward the hospital, lights flashing, siren wailing. The diAngelos' Mercedes was parked carelessly in the lot, its doors left open.

But the only things Carole really saw were the veterinarian's pickup truck and the county vet's wagon. That was when Carole knew the worst. Two veterinarians always had to sign a certificate before a horse could be destroyed.

"Cobalt!" she screamed, jumping from the car almost before it stopped.

Lisa and Stevie came running out of the stable. Lisa reached Carole first and put her arm around her. Stevie had tears streaming down her face.

"It's too late, Carole," she said. "He was too badly hurt! They had to do it. He would never heal. It was that long bone in his foreleg -- it was shattered. He just lay there. And then it was over."

Yeah, that about says it all. The next day, Lisa and Stevie tell Carole how Max had them jumping again, and Veronica brought Cobalt down the hill at a gallop and expected him to make the jump and land on a downward slope. Carole knows that "they did the right thing. Cobalt's life was over. He was born to run with the wind, not limp," but she tells Stevie and Lisa that she's quitting riding forever.

Stevie and Lisa do some research on Max's grandfather. There's no info in the papers, and Mrs. Reg, Max's mother and Max I's daughter-in-law, won't give up anything. They finally run into this old guy, Mr. Thompson, who took riding lessons from Max I. Apparently Max I was the strictest, most boring guy ever, and all the stories the students make up about him are much more fun than he ever was. They also spot Veronica, with a cast on her left arm, reading a book about horsemanship and practicing her jumping skills with a chair in the library. It's less weird than it sounds ... no, I take that back. It still sounds very weird, but it does make some sense: Stevie says that "Veronica's had a zillion lessons and a fabulous horse, but she never listened and she never learned. She thought she was too good to make a mistake, but she was wrong. She knows that now. Cobalt's life was a horrible price, but at least she learned something from it."

Meanwhile, Carole agrees to come back to PH not to ride, but to help Mrs. Reg sort out the extra tack that they took on the MTO. While she's there, she sees the newest litter of PH kittens, including one feisty, determined black kitten. Mrs. Reg also busts out her first long, rambling, seemingly-unrelated-to-the-situation-at-hand-but-clearly-has-a-hidden-meaning horse story, about all the different horses she's ridden in her life, but she's never had a favourite.

Another Saturday. Colonel Hanson is heading out to play tennis and then go on a date with a woman named Barbara Lerner, which Carole takes much better than I would if my mother had died seven months ago. Carole reads a scintillating textbook about pyramids, then, without thinking, takes the bus to PH, where she sobs and then falls asleep in Cobalt's stall. When she wakes up, she hears Veronica arguing, with her father, who desperately wants to buy Delilah for "Ronnie" (HAHA). Veronica, to her credit, says that the insurance money they got for Cobalt doesn't have anything to do with it and that she doesn't want another horse until she can take care of him.

Carole realizes that not only has she come to the stable wearing riding clothes, she's ready to ride again. As she heads off to find Max, she sees Mrs. Reg trying to get the feisty little black kitten down from a rafter in the tack room. He's so contrary that Carole decides that he should be named Snowball, but there's no famous horse named Snowball, so Mrs. Reg suggests that "if he's not a stable cat, he doesn't have to have a stable name" and that Carole should ask her dad if she can have him.

Carole tells Max she wants to rejoin the class and Max of course says yes, but that she won't be riding Delilah. Carole takes that to mean that Mr. diAngelo bought her after all, but that's not it: she's pregnant, and Cobalt is the babydaddy.

Everyone is thrilled to see Carole again, and she figures out the message behind Mrs. Reg's horse story:

"What made you decide to come back?" Lisa asked.

"There were a lot of things. I think you were right in a way when you said I was horse shy. But not just about any horse -- it was Cobalt. It hurt so much when he died that I was afraid I might get hurt again if something like that happened to another horse. But when I saw what Veronica had learned -- well, I thought if there's hope for her, then there's hope for me. Anyway, the only thing worse than losing something you care about is not having something you care about at all. I learned that when Mom died.

Stevie and Lisa sat quietly. "There was something else," Carole continued. "I finally realized that no matter how much I cared about him, Cobalt wasn't mine. He belonged to somebody else."

"But you rode him more than Veronica did!" Lisa reminded her.

"I did, that's right. And I rode him better. But Mrs. Reg had the final lesson to me, though she didn't say it in so many words. There are lots of horses, some good, some bad, most mixes of good and bad. And I want to ride them all!"

And that's it. They eat ice cream, they schmooze, they dance, everything's fine. Yay!

This one is too sad for me to be really negative about it. I am always surprised at how early Cobalt was killed off (of course, back then BB thought there were going to be just four books) and how much personality he had (albeit, slightly conflicting personalities, such as difficult/sweet, beautiful, kittenish). And he continues to be a very personality-filled horse through the rest of the series, especially after Delilah gets pregnant and barefoot and basically exists to be the foal's mother.

Points of Interest:
  • I am now 25 and have still never seen anything from Hermes, nor have I figured out what Perugina candies are. I must lead a deprived life.
  • When Max breaks everyone into teams for horse games, he puts Carole, Stevie, Meg, Lorraine, and Red on one time, and Veronica, Joe, Betsy, Lisa, and Adam Levine on another. Like, really? Carole, Stevie, and Red on one team? In what universe is that fair?
  • 'K, so Cobalt dies jumping a downhill slope, exactly what Max reamed Veronica for on the MTO. I can't imagine a downhill slope being the best or safest place to teach a bunch of twelve-year-olds to jump, not to mention that there are plenty of other (flat) places around PH to set up jumps, and did he really think Veronica listened to him at all when he yelled at her the first time? After it happened, Veronica told her parents that it was Max's fault, because he shouldn't have set up the jump that way. Well, I certainly don't think it was Max's fault, but I'm not sure he should have set up the jump that way either.
  • Another PH tradition is to name the cats after famous horses, like Eclipse (a Thoroughbred), Copperbottom (a Quarter Horse), and Sir Archie (also a Thoroughbred). Mrs. Reg things it's "about time to use some of the Standardbreds," and suggests Messenger, Hambletonian, Dutchman, Yankee, and Dan Patch. This is a much cuter and more realistic tradition than the soda whip, and it's nice to know all the cats aren't named Seattle Slew and Affirmed (or Just Victory and Canady Red). Plus, can you imagine PH in the year 2060, when they'd have to have cats called Afleet Alex and Funny Cide?
  • I particularly enjoy how Carole thinks that "People who told horse stories usually told about the unlikely undersized weakling foal who grew up to take blue ribbons at the National Horse Show. Real life, Carole knew, wasn't like that." Or the Kentucky Derby, perhaps. Roses, then, not blue ribbons.
  • Veronica actually never objects to being called Ronnie; Carole is the one who is surprised that Veronica would let someone call her that.
  • This was the second book reprinted in 2007-2008. As far as I know, they made no text changes, like tape players to CD players, the way they did in the first book.

Caitlin's Way: Caitlin is so complicated she doesn't even understand herself.

Season 1, Episode 19: Playing Caitlin
Aired: August 13, 2000

We're starting out this episode in what looks to be drama class. I'm sure these kids probably have something like fifteen different classes as required by whatever plot the show is going for at the moment, and at this particular juncture, the show is going for high school plays/teenagers are emo, right? So the kids are in drama, and they're all in it together. I proceed to not understand how this school system works, but it's not really important at this point.

Anyway, they're all in drama. They are talking about something, which leads to the teacher whipping out Caitlin's play and reciting a few lines. The play Caitlin has written is obviously about her life. Naturally, Caitlin finds nothing as interesting as herself, so her play is all about how no one understands her and then she gets arrested for stealing a camera. The teacher just loves her play, but Caitlin understandably is pissed that the teacher read the passage in front of everyone.

Enter Caitlin's whiny voice over about why adults want to get inside the heads of teenagers. Or, gasp, maybe they just want to get inside Caitlin's head! Honestly, I don't see how anyone would want to go in there. They'd just be bored out of their mind.

Returning from the horrible opening sequence (I'm still not over its awfulness), Griffen and his friends, Eric and some other guy, are playing basketball while Eric tells them that he's signed them up to put on a play instead of writing a paper for drama. Initially Griffen is hesitant, but then he decides that this is a good idea. Although Eric and the other guy tell him that they can't use Griffen's play because there are no girls in it. I think it's about time that Griffen just embrace his gayness. Seriously, the signs could not be any clearer at this point.

Cue Caitlin. She wanders onto the basketball court and Eric falls on her like an small, excited dog in attempts to convince her to let them put on her play. Eventually she says yes, although she doesn't really know why. I imagine it's probably another way for her to be the center of attention, regardless of what she's actually saying. So they're all happy. On to the auditions, leading to a ridiculous series of girls bouncing up and down and hiccuping and trying to act seductive, or something like that. Only then this blond girl shows up and sweeps Griffen off his feet because she's blond and kind of pushy. I don't remember her name, so henceforth she will be referred to as Blond Girl. Yeah, I'm not feeling creative today.

Immediately Caitlin starts being critical of Blond Girl's acting, because Blond Girl can't possibly understand Caitlin's motives for being a whiny bitch. Eric is over there getting into his role as the cop that arrests Caitlin, leading to some ridiculous scenes involving roller blading that were not needed. Eventually Eric decides he wants a bigger role that will include a motorcycle, but Caitlin refuses to write that in, dashing Eric's delusions of grandeur. Only then Blond Girl still isn't getting Caitlin's mysteriousness, despite the script supposedly being right there. I don't see how this could be such a problem, but it nevertheless is and this inevitably leads Blond Girl to the decision that the only way to understand Caitlin is to live Caitlin's life.

Don't worry! This is not Single White Female. Blond Girl decides to spend a night in a back alley, where she sits in cat pee and then decides to go home after Griffen somehow wanders across her and asks her what the hell she's doing.

After this, Blond Girl is further confused. She does not understand Caitlin! How could she? The script, you see, is not clear! No one understands why Caitlin stole this stupid camera and why she allowed herself to get caught when she could have hopped over a fence to freedom had she just left the camera where she dropped it. I guess these people don't understand the concept of show not tell, because they need it spelled out for them. Blond Girl decides that she needs to come on to Eric the cop, because I suppose she figures that Caitlin is a whore. Then she opts for crying, because she figures Caitlin is girlier than Caitlin would like to admit in public. That's when Caitlin gets fed up and walks out on the production so she can ride Bandit out to a field and then angst over a copy of her script.

So then she has her great moment of enlightenment. They are right! The script makes no sense because it's just so damn vague. Standing in the field with Bandit, Caitlin plucks a pencil out of thin air and edits her script. Then I guess she races Bandit back to the wherever she came from and shows Blond Girl and Co. the new script at the dress rehearsal. Blond Girl refuses to do the new pages because she can't remember the lines and should therefore probably start looking for another possible career, and Eric throws up and refuses to be a part of the play. So the rehearsal would be falling apart if not for Caitlin's insistence that she play herself. She should have done it all along!

And then we cut to a monologue about how Caitlin wanted to steal the camera because that would mean she's free and would stop having such annoying parental issues and would hopefully stop crying for attention. Everyone at the dress rehearsal loves it, and then I guess Caitlin goes on to personally deliver her private issues to hundreds of her classmates at later performances.

  • "Come on, Caitlin. No one ever comes to our plays. Not after last year's production of Cats." I've never seen Cats, but I can imagine a high school production of it would be horrible.
  • "It's in the literary tradition of The Outsider with stylistic reference to The Phantom Menace." Wow, am I the only one that thinks this play is a really bad idea? Is it even possible to make a stylistic reference to The Phantom Menace? And are we really going to compare Caitlin's life to Albert Camus seriously? Because I think we need to take a good look at this show before we do that.
  • The Blond Girl's audition is her in a Halloween witch costume as she reads from Macbeth. Griffen's response is: "You never see blond witches!" I...yeah, no. I'm just going to keep going.
  • "Black everything. Cheap jewelry, sullen makeup." The Blond Girl takes note of Caitlin's appearance and hits it spot on. Cheap and sullen. She said it better than I ever could.
  • What is with everyone just casually wandering into the public bathrooms? Caitlin strolls into the boy's bathroom, the guys just walk right into the girl's bathrooms. This is a public high school, not a private liberal arts college. Okay?
  • "My dad won't let me shave because I'm too young. This is my face!" Caitlin's monologue inspires Griffen's other friend to rebel and start shaving. My, how Caitlin inspires us all!
Okay, I swear I am reading, but I'm a bit busy at the moment, so these Caitlin's Way episodes more than provide me enough fodder for the blog. I'll have a few books ready to post next week.

Sep 4, 2008

Caitlin's Way: Money = Trust





Season 1, Episode 16: Caitlin's Trust
Aired: July 23, 2000

We're delving a little further into season one with Caitlin's Trust in this review, where the ultimate question is answered: what should garner more trust? The unconditional love and support of family members who feed, clothe, and shelter you or a trust fund that sits around collecting interest? Rest assured, we are about to find out.

This episode opens with Griffen and Caitlin walking home from school. Griffen has received a new e-mail from his "cyber pen pal" Jocelyn about the brilliance of Radiohead, and Griffen is reading aloud her e-mail to Caitlin, who isn't impressed. Griffen adores Jocelyn, who is French and therefore "deeper" than American girls because they don't diet and have no body image issues. Caitlin is about to make fun of this, but that's when she finds a government check in the mail that she of course rips open to discover that Dori and Jim are being paid $300 every unspecified number of weeks or months or something because they've taken in Caitlin and it's standard government procedure to hand cash to foster families. Griffen takes this in stride and goes that extra step further by telling Caitlin jokingly that she has a horse and is a drain on the family resources. Because Caitlin has no sense of humor and is basically a really horrible meld of Cindy and Melanie with an eyebrow piercing, she grabs onto this phrase and runs with it. A drain on the family? How dare they think that!

Enter horrible opening sequence. God, it's so bad.

Continuing on, Caitlin approaches Dori, who is nursing a baby moose. I don't know why, so I'm just going to skip that. Caitlin tells Dori that they need more apples for Bandit, who is an apple whore. Dori says that yeah, sure, she'll get them or something but then she dares to mention that she thinks Caitlin is feeding Bandit too many apples. Bandit will become spoiled! Caitlin immediately reverts to her street days, I guess, and gets all offended, but before she can really blow a gasket over this stupid comment, Dori pulls out a vintage jacket she found while she was going through her old clothes for some themed high school reunion she and Jim are going to. Caitlin accepts the jacket, but is not swayed from her earlier anger. She'll get the damn apples herself!

Caitlin puts on her jacket and rides Bandit into town. She basically parks him and ties him up to a lamppost, then admires herself and her jacket in the reflection of a window. Right about here I'm thinking that the jacket is way too small for her bustiness and right when that thought goes through my head she bends down and rips the jacket to shreds. Poor Caitlin. She is too busty.

Meanwhile, Griffen and his friend Eric discover an eating contest at the local diner. The winner will get to go to Paris! Thrilled that he will be able to proclaim his love to his "cyber pen pal" in person, Griffen starts to eat lots of hamburgers.

Moving back to Caitlin, she's busy throwing the ripped jacket at Dori and demanding to know why she doesn't get anything new out of her aunt and uncle who selflessly took her in, because shelter and security are secondary to shiny new things! Dori really doesn't know what to say to this, but then Jim drives up in their brand new shiny Jeep. Yes, a JEEP. Everyone fawns over the new car, while Caitlin grumbles to herself about how the car is probably bought on her government money fund, so she figures it's really hers. Dori and Jim then go out to the reunion, but not before Caitlin can make some snide comment about all the money they're making because she's a bitch.

So, left without supervision, Caitlin, Griffen and Eric decide to drive the Jeep to town so the boys can go eat more hamburgers at the diner. On her way back to the house, I guess Caitlin drove through a swamp in the middle of Montana because her windshield is so full of dead insects that she can no longer see the road. That's when she randomly veers off the road and crashes the Jeep. A hospital visit later, Caitlin is grounded and Jim is rethinking this whole raising a juvenile delinquent thing. Caitlin suffers one of those I-can't-stand-staying-away-from-my-wonder-horse issues and goes to ride Bandit despite being grounded, but Griffen stops her and insists that if she does that she'll be moved to a new foster home for sure and he wants her to stay.

Then Caitlin had to go get all touching about Jim and Dori's routine in the morning, and how great it is being at Lowe Ranch, and I actually liked that part. So Griffen goes to plead Caitlin's case to his parents, and he reveals that he was sort of in on driving the Jeep too, and Caitlin is further touched, and she does her best sincere apology and so she can stay. Also, the money the government has been sending Jim and Dori has been put into a trust fund.

So while Caitlin and Griffen are doing their community service as part of Jim's requirement of paying their dues to society, Eric wins the eating contest and gets the France trip. He's all thrilled because this means he can go to Paris and impress Jocelyn with his 20 touchdowns, only Griffen has a surprise in store for everyone. Jocelyn is actually a guy, which he just now discovered, further cementing my belief that Griffen is gay.

We end with a lovely voice over from Caitlin about how Jim and Dori won her trust by giving her money. So, you see, the trust fund is more important after all. Thank you for sharing such wise moral advice, Caitlin!

  • While Caitlin is recovering from the car accident, Eric convinces Griffen not to say he was in on driving the Jeep to town because he wouldn't want to go to jail, would he? Yeah, something tells me grand theft auto just isn't going to be applied here, Eric.
  • Still with the "she broke the law!" At least Dori has the sense to say, "yeah, but you don't have to press charges." Seriously.
  • Grant, I suppose the second policeman in town after Jim, sees Caitlin driving the Jeep and turns to follow her up to the crash site. All this time he's bemoaning Caitlin's stupidity, basically, but I can't tell if it's supposed to be voice over or the worst syncing that ever existed.
Just to let everyone know, Caitlin's Way is on The N, some network for teens I did not know existed until now. So set your DVR or whatever and follow along!