Sep 4, 2008

Caitlin's Way: You can't comprehend Caitlin's issues! Do not try!





Season 1, Episode 4: Boundaries
Aired: March 12, 2000

So, I guess by sheer luck I started out this series with an episode relatively close to the beginning. Caitlin (Lindsay Felton) is still sort of fresh off the Philadelphia streets, where (as the opening sequence suggests) she spent all her time dying her hair, acting emo, and trying to trick people out of their money. Really, who falls for the three-card trick? Do people still do this, or is it something you only see on television?

This episode starts with Griffen Lowe, Caitlin's cousin, snooping around in her room. He rummages through her things, stares at a CD case as if he has no idea what it could possibly be, and somehow winds up in her underwear drawer. From this, I suppose we can deduce that Griffen has been repressing some dirty sexual urge and now that his female cousin is living with him he's going to start acting on his desires. Only in a very "I'm fifteen and harmless" sort of way. Actually, I had the distinct impression that Griffen is gay. Although that might be because at one point he goes on and on about this green shirt that will look so good with his new shoes. And also because Caitlin seems to routinely beat him up.

Okay, anyway, Caitlin finds him wandering around in her room and she does not like this. Griffen doesn't like it either, because her room used to be his game room, and really he was just up there looking for this old Nintendo cartridge, but Caitlin doesn't buy this and throws a pillow at him. Yes, Griffen, let this be a lesson to you! Stay out, or Caitlin will batter you with more feather-filled objects! Well, everyone is all "oooh, she threw something! she's so hard core!" and Griffen retreats.

Enter really ugly opening sequence. Seriously.

So Caitlin is listening to her music when she hears Bandit, the buckskin mustang wonder horse she saved or something, causing a ruckus in the barn. Caitlin rushes down to the barn and starts talking to Bandit about his hurt neck, because I guess he hurt it, and then starts to project her problems onto him. Does Bandit really want to say? Won't Bandit try to stick around a few more days? Then she sleeps in the barn with the horse. Her aunt wakes her up in the morning and blabbers about testing boundaries and something or another, giving Caitlin pause to mope about her situation. Then they eat breakfast. All hell breaks loose over the last pancake, which Griffen claims as his own by licking it and then shoving it in his mouth. Caitlin then compares her new life to jail and goes off to ruin Griffen's "best" shirt. The two kids scuffle around in the gravel for a minute before aunt and uncle (Dori and Jim) break it up and force them to do something together. Therefore they will be cooking dinner when they get home from school tomorrow. Boo, is essentially the verdict delivered by the kids.

They go to school. Griffen's friend tries to scuff up Griffen's perfect white shoes (...) and Caitlin gets in the guy's face. Stop trying to scuff up my prissy cousin's white shoes! And Griffen is all offended because his friend was just trying to be funny and he leaves in a huff because Caitlin is so serious all the time and does not like to be social, nor understands how to be anything other than emo. This all comes to a head after their Lit class, where Caitlin seems to not understand what the river means in Huck Finn, giving Griffen (who happens to be in the same class, of course) the chance to jump in and give his answer that it's all about life's journey! Caitlin acts emo some more. Then she storms into the men's bathroom to confront Griffen over this stupid river and how she was going to say that it's about something else all literary and meaningful that is also right, only it's more right because it's Caitlin's answer. Then she squirts him with water from the sink. Ohmigosh! She's even more hard core! Feather pillows and squirting water! It's too much for Griffen's rural mindset to compute! So he tries to squirt his Fresca all over her, but misses and gets the teacher instead. Damn. They both get detention and have to clean the bathroom. Something I don't see happening at all. High school teachers are never that creative.

Meanwhile, Dori tries to take Bandit out of the barn without a lead for the nonexistent blacksmith and of course she loses him. So Bandit is off running around and Dori and Jim have to go find him as Dori whispers about how much Bandit means to Caitlin.

Then the kids miss their bus, although frankly they missed it because Caitlin had to go into a long ass talk about how her life is so much more difficult than Griffen's because sometimes she didn't know where home was in Philadelphia. Yeah, Griffen, don't you dare try to tell Caitlin that you have problems too. She doesn't care about your problems because hers are always worse. Always. So they walk home. And nearly get gored by a bull. And they argue some more about how much their situation sucks and about how Caitlin doesn't have to do anything anyone tells her because she's hard core.

Eventually a neighbor comes along and Griffen abandons Caitlin to get a ride home in the neighbor's truck. She won't get in because there's a pig in the bed. Or something that looks like a pig. Anyway, Caitlin covers up this pig abhorrence with just being mean and irritating because she can, and Griffen goes off with the truck. Only then he sees Bandit running around and has to alert Caitlin. So he alerts Caitlin and miraculously they find Dori and Jim and Bandit. They all sort of converge together in a very convenient manner that would never possibly happen realistically. And Caitlin uses her magical horsey ability to calm wild mustangs and all is well. Perhaps Montana or Calgary or wherever the hell she is won't be so bad after all!

And they walk home, Caitlin and Griffen's problems are weirdly shoved to the side because Caitlin has magical horse-calming abilities, and then presumably they eat pizza.

  • Caitlin calms Bandit with her magical words of "whoa!" Griffen says: "Dad, did you see that? Did you see that?" Jim: "I'm standing right here, Griff." It becomes apparent that Jim has the best lines in this series. Obviously he saw Caitlin's magic. He was, as he said, right there.
  • Griffen continues his insane blubbering over Caitlin's horse magic and she says, "It comes with the territory." What territory? What is she talking about?
  • You know what I dislike? When they replace the main horse actor with another horse actor that is obviously different. Like, the main horse that plays Bandit has no blaze. The actor they have for running scenes has a blaze. It's obvious the horse has a blaze. You can't miss it.
So, that is my first Caitlin's Way episode. I hope you enjoyed the innocent teenage angst and melodrama.

Sep 2, 2008

Book Rec: Blue Moon

Blue Moon
by Marilyn Halvorson
Published: 1994, 2004

Can Bobbie Jo take a beat-up old horse and turn her into a champion barrel racer?
The first thing I have to say about this book is that it's 109 pages, and the type is relatively large. Given that the actual story starts on page 7 (this is the first book I've seen that starts the page numbers at the title page), it's actually 102 pages of story. If you're really focused, you can finish this book in a matter of minutes.

It's first person, told from B.J.'s viewpoint and starts at an auction. B.J. has scraped together all her money, some $700, and went to the auction to pick up a yearling that she can train to become a barrel racer. Only when she got to the auction she wound up buying a blue roan mare. She blames this mainly on the mare's color, because she's been obsessed with blue roans ever since reading a picture book way back when. When she goes to pay for the mare, she's ten dollars short and told that if she can't come up with the money the mare will be resold. She races out to find $10, because there are kill buyers at the auction and the mare in question was in some danger of being bought for meat.

While looking for $10, she runs into Cole. Cole is all seventeen and cocky and calls B.J. Blue Jeans, which B.J. absolutely hates. But she grabs him and demands that he give her ten dollars, which after mocking her a little he eventually gives her about eight dollars and change. She rushes back to give the cashier her money and insists that she'll get the rest ($1.25) later. The cashier just rolls his eyes and makes up for it himself, so she's got her horse. Only the horse hates trailers, so as she's the only person there that can get this horse on the trailer, Cole appears again and helps her out. But then he gets fired for walking off his job to help her. Poor Cole. B.J. tells herself that it's not her fault he was being stupid, and takes the horse home to her less than thrilled family.

Her family are dairy farmers, and they need work over the summer. So eventually B.J. gives in to her guilt over getting Cole fired and finds him in school the next day to offer him this government assistance program job or whatnot, because she can't do it given that she's family and all. He takes her up on her offer after initially refusing because he's the proud cowboy type. He also has long, curly blond hair...which I have to blame on the fact that this was first published in 1994. Really, I can't imagine who in their right mind would allow that to happen to their head.

Well, anyway. Cole is also pretty good with horses, so he likes watching B.J. deal with the mare, who is all beaten up and angry, but remarkably quiet and good under saddle. He also won't let B.J. pay him back his $8 and change, insisting he's got a stake in the mare...much to B.J.'s annoyance. He begins to help her out training the mare, which she eventually names Blue Moon because Cole's crippled dad comes over to look at her and says something about how rare a horse like it is. B.J. keeps training Blue Moon for barrel racing, and she and Cole start striking up a friendship that you know is eventually going to turn into a relationship. Only then he has to go start acting weird about Blue Moon and B.J. gets all offended when she thinks he's not totally supportive of their chances at winning. But they get over it and go to the barrel racing event thing, and Blue Moon wins the competition.

On the way back to the dairy farm, they nearly get run off the road and Cole has the chance to tell her why he's been acting so weird. As it happens, his dad used to be a big time horse trainer before they were run off the road by a drunk driver, crippling him and causing him to lose his job. So they only have these three horses and are basically poor, but because his dad used to be someone he knows who Blue Moon is. She's a mare that was stolen from some big name ranch, giving B.J. the chance to do the right thing and call up the previous owners. The previous owners are brilliant and wonderful and they ask B.J. how much she paid for the horse. Then they tell her that she can keep the mare if she's willing to breed Blue Moon to Cole's fantastic stallion so they can have the foal. B.J. is okay with this. The end.

So yeah, like I said it's really short. But the weird thing about it is B.J. and Cole are actually good characters. B.J. is spunky and pretty confident, blowing the Typical Perfect Horse Story Girl out of the water, and I liked Cole despite his horrible hair. I just pretended it didn't exist, and managed to get through the story just fine.

I don't know what I think about the ending, as it flies out of nowhere and seems fairly unrealistic, but that's usually how the girl-might-have-to-give-up-horse-but-doesn't plot goes. All in all, I'd say it's the strongest 109 page horse story I've ever read. I don't know if that's saying something or not, but it's an enjoyable read that will take under an hour.

So...I think I have Dead Heat coming up this week. As well as Chance Meeting by Laura Moore and Ashleigh's Hope, because I have to get through all the Bentley books. I've also decided to start reviewing some television on this blog, mainly because I decided to Google "thoroughbred series" and "wildfire" together to see what happened. Naturally I got reviews for each being compared to each other. So I decided to bite the bullet. If other people think this, obviously I have to finally watch this stupid show, right? So I'm going to watch Wildfire. I'm also going to start watching Caitlyn's Way, mainly because it's syndicated and easy to find completely random episodes. So we'll have some television-related blog entries starting this week, probably.

That's all the news here.

Sep 1, 2008

I read this book and all I got was this empty feeling.

A Horse of Her Own
by Annie Wedekind
Published: June 2008

Annie Wedekind is a new author, just experiencing the first blush of publication and enjoying the thrill of seeing her words in print. Congratulations, Annie! Your hard work (I presume you worked hard, but whatever) has payed off. What's more, you have a very cute website. I admire all of that.

But it's not going to stop me from recapping this book to the standards I usually reserve for Thoroughbred. (Annie, if you've read Thoroughbred, don't worry. I love it and will be the first to defend it. Think of this as a very positive situation for you.)

Summary:
Fourteen-year-old Jane Ryan has always dreamed of having a horse of her own—but so long as she gets to ride her favorite school horse, Beau, at Sunny Acres farm, she’s content. And this is the summer she means to try out for the advanced riding class.

But just as camp begins, Jane receives heartbreaking news about Beau. She loses, not just her favorite horse, but also her chance to ride in the end-of-summer competition. When her trainer asks for her help with an out-of-control chestnut warmblood, Lancelot, a newcomer to the barn, she has no choice but to say yes.

There’s another new addition to the farm: Ben Reyes, the grandson of the barn's manager. As Jane struggles to go on without Beau, and to make Lancelot the great horse she believes him to be, her feelings for Ben, her relationships with the privileged group of girls she rides with, and her painful, joyous road to self-discovery all lead to a heart-pounding conclusion that is truly a new beginning. Only Jane’s faith in Lancelot, and her own rediscovered skill and strength, can see her through the hard journey toward a horse of her own.
The Kirkus Review calls this "probably the most honest horse book since National Velvet." I have a huge problem with this statement for three reasons. The first among them is that National Velvet was published in 1935. Am I really to expect that the world has been without an "honest" horse book for 73 years? Secondly, this isn't an honest horse book. This is basically Camp Saddlebrook and Melanie's Last Ride combined. That's right. Think on that for a minute. Thirdly, I'm pretty sure the Kirkus Review only mentions National Velvet because this book shamelessly references National Velvet's plot as being similar to its own.

I'm going to focus first on the author for a minute. Annie is originally from Louisville, where she learned how to ride on a farm similar to the farm she depicts in her novel. There's also a note in the back of the book about how the setting of her novel is so very similar to the setting of her youth (as in, it is the same), but don't worry all you people who knew her when she was young. She didn't write you into her novel, or anything. Not to worry! Oh, except for that Beau horse (which is pronounced "Boo," so why they didn't just spell it Boo is beyond me), who I guess existed at one point.

Yeah, so from all of that are we immediately suspicious that our main character is going to be a Mary Sue? Well, let's find out, shall we?

Meet Jane Ryan. She's the daughter of two college professors and lives in downtown Louisville, which therefore makes her unworthy to all the other suburban-raised kids in her riding class. Except for Robin, who is rich and suburban-raised herself, and somehow manages to be accepted by the rich snobs while dutifully playing Jane's best friend. The rich snobs are Alyssa and Jennifer, who have snubbed Jane for about five solid years. Then there's Jessica, Alyssa and Jennifer's third portion of their triumvirate of bitchiness. Jessica drifts back and forth, mostly loyal to Alyssa, but she sometimes throws Jane a brief glimpse of hope that she'll be included in their clique, which mainly just confuses Jane. Jane, you see, so desperately wants to belong.

Now, the thing here is that everyone has their own horse except for Jane. Jane is painfully aware of this fact. Riding school horses, you see, is so very terrible and Jane so wants her own horse and you see the issue, I'm sure. In the early goings of the book she begs her father one last time for her very own horse and he tells her again that they just can't afford it (yet they've been sending her to a private school up through 8th grade...because they are college professors and public school is not good or challenging enough for their socially awkward daughter). Jane responds by bursting into tears.

Jane just takes this melodrama and applies it to her determination to get into the Advanced I class on Beau, her trusty school horse. During their last lesson before their instructor, Susan, decides on their placement for camp, the other evil bitchy girl, Emily, arrives with a brand new horse. It is the fantastical chestnut gelding Lancelot. Only he's crazy. And Emily sort of beats the crap out of him with her crop. And now he hates crops. Of course he does. So Susan sticks Emily in Advanced II and thus Jane gets to be in Advanced I. Camp starts. This is all fairly uneventful until Jane runs into the boy of her dreams, Ben. Only she spends most of this meeting being even more socially awkward than normal and talking to animals. Poor, poor Jane.

In the early goings of the camp, instructor Susan has the Advanced I girls go over this cross country course, having them all go over this crazy big hedge jump without really informing them that this jump is involved in the course. Ben is hidden in the trees to make sure they all go over this jump, and only two actually do -- Jane and Jessica. Alyssa and Jennifer opt out of the jump entirely, getting reprimanded by Susan as they hold firm in their belief that they were being responsible by refusing to jump such an obstacle. I can't really say what the whole point was of this giant hedge jump other than Susan expecting everyone to do as she commands, but whatever. After this reprimand, Susan goes and informs Jane that Beau was sold to one of the younger kids and so Jane has no mount. There's some talk about the owners of the barn deciding to get another horse for the stable, but this never actually materializes. I kept expecting someone to tell Jane not to worry because a new horse is coming along, but no one does.

You want to know why? No one tells Jane about the new horse because Emily has thrown a temper tantrum and left camp, dumping Lancelot in a stall with a bucket of grain. Lancelot colics, and while Jane is all moping around in the middle of the night, she runs into the drama in the barn with Ben and his grandfather, Jose, who are both taking care of the panicked gelding. Only Jose decides to put the horse back in the stall to let him roll because that's supposed to be just fine? Apparently it's okay to let a colicking horse roll all over the place and the only danger to a horse in this condition is that they might smack a leg against the sides of their stall? Is there some reasoning behind why Annie is rewriting EVERYTHING I've ever known about treating colic? Horse people, help me out here.

So, after saving Lancelot's life, Jane becomes the gelding's personal Jesus. She walks out to the horse in his paddock and offers him grass and he's all "grass!" and lets her lead him around. Everyone is shocked. I...am not, I've got to say. So then Susan let's it be known that she bought Lancelot from Emily's parents and she wants Jane to ride him.

Let's just get this out now: Jessica has already told Jane that the other girls don't like her because they're intimidated by her. Also, it's pretty apparent that Jane is the best rider there ever was in the history of this barn. Also, Alyssa calls her Ms. Goody, and she's right. Jane is a perfect goody-goody. She may be a dirty mess who wears high-waisted jeans and Keds from 1986, but just because she has no fashion sense doesn't make her any less of a perfect brat. After this Ms. Goody moment, it becomes screamingly apparent that Jane is just that. And it's highly annoying.

So, right when Jane starts harboring these feeling for Ben, Jessica comes along and swoops him up. She also transforms from a somewhat sympathetic and interesting character into a two-dimensional nut case who shows two emotions: jealousy and pissiness. Therefore the main antagonist switches from Alyssa to Jessica in the bat of an eye.

Meanwhile, Jane continues to ride Lancelot and he continues to accidentally beat the crap out of her. Jose and Susan get into this random yelling match about how Jane shouldn't be riding Lancelot at all because he's not hers and she'll just get all heartbroken when she has to be taken off of him again? Like...suck it up, Jane. And who are these people to really care whether or not she has a horse? And where is this horse the owners were buying and moving to the barn? Huh? HUH?

Anyway, Ben and Jane start taking Lancelot on trail rides and Jessica is not pleased about this. At one point she strolls up to them in Lancelot's stall and informs Ben she's going to go swimming. She proceeds to strip her shirt off to show him how wonderful her breasts look in a red bikini. Jane just blushes again and realizes she'll never have a chest like Jessica's. This is a pretty clunky area, obviously.

So, let me see here. Let's just get to the main point. Jane decides she's going to ride in the end of camp show with Lancelot, only she's going to ride in Advanced I. Because Lancelot is kind of a lunatic, Jane winds up doing more Advanced II work with him because no one wants Lancelot to fly into a cross country jump and kill them both. Only Jane is not satisfied with this. So she has Ben spy on Advanced I classes for her, and he gets her the jumping tests for the show, and Jessica is further pissed off. Ben finally tells Jane that he had told Jessica about the hedge jump from the beginning of camp, with expectations that Jessica would tell everyone else in Advanced I. Well, Jessica didn't tell Jane. Wow, shocking. So Ben and Jessica get into a fight about Jane.

Eventually, Jane falls off of Lancelot again and injures her shoulder. Fighting through the pain, she enters the Advanced I show anyway and wins. Afterward Susan gives Lancelot to Jane (we all saw that coming, right?), but only after they all discover that Lancelot isn't actually the horse they all thought he was. Gasp! Who is this horse? Where did Emily's dad get him?

Well, those questions aren't answered because Annie is working on a sequel. I'm going to predict right now that the sequel is going to be about Lancelot's real background and then there's going to be a plotline that will concern Jane possibly having to give him up, but in the end she gets to keep him. Right? If that's not exactly on the money, I'm sure it's a variation on the same theme.

  • There are two things that started to annoy me in their repetition: blushing and calling everything crazy. At one point someone yells something about "that crazy horse! That's crazy!" Like...there are synonyms for crazy. Lots of them. Also, the blushing. Jane may be shy, but I don't think it's possible to blush that often. It happened nearly three times per chapter. There are 21 chapters. That's too much.
  • I appreciated Robin the most in the entire book. I expected her to fall into the typical secondary character meant to solely support the main character's brilliance, but she does have an little plotline of her own. The unfortunate thing about her plotline is how lame it is. Her problem is she doesn't want to compete, which pretty much boils down to the repeated insistence that no one is as good as Jane.
  • Annie was trying for some humor in this book. You could really tell she wanted readers to laugh at the antics and the characters constantly lapsing into British accents, but it felt really forced and unfunny to me. Actually, Robin and Jane always seemed to act like they were drunk whenever they were together, which was probably not what Annie was going for at all.
  • Beau is sold to a ten-year-old girl named Megan, giving Jane the opportunity to become Megan's mentor. There was a lot of sappiness that was not needed at all here. About half of Megan's scenes could have been cut entirely and Jane's character would have been stronger for it.
  • Jane never does anything wrong when she's riding. In fact, she always does everything right. What's more, she only falls off during accidents involving twigs or things that happen to slap at Lancelot. Therefore, the only reason Lancelot is dumping Jane is because Emily is such a bitch. Really.
  • At the show, Alyssa and Jennifer's older brothers show up. Jane's older sister, Lily, also shows up. Immediately I just knew the brothers were going to take an interest in Jane and Lily. What happened? Oh, they totally stared at them. It was a wonderful opportunity for me to feel smug.
Here's my final verdict on Jane. She's not a Mary Sue. A bit of a self-insert, she may well be, but mostly she just suffers from being a typical main character in a typical young adult horse story. She's the girl that doesn't have everything, doesn't own a horse and desperately wants one, works hard, is a "natural" at riding, is almost too down to earth, gets beaten up severely and rises above her injuries, and wins her show/class/whatever before randomly getting a horse of her own in the end. God, that girl and plot gets annoying eventually.

So, Annie, I'm sorry to say, but "most honest horse book since National Velvet" this story is not, because it's basically every juvenile horse story I've read since January...and that's a lot of them. It's a good first try, and I will most assuredly read the sequel, because I mainly want to see if I'm right about the plot. Otherwise, A Horse of Her Own is about as original as its title. Which, considering I already reviewed Joanna Campbell's A Horse of Her Own, is not very original at all.

Aug 31, 2008

Book Rec: Another Kind of Cowboy

Another Kind of Cowboy
by Susan Juby
Published: 2007

I'll state first that I liked this book. If ever there was a book deserving of a serious recommendation, this is that book. In fact, I'm not sure I can come up with a suitably snarky review for the blog, and I don't really even want to give up spoilers. What is wrong with me?

Well. Here's the summary:

For Alex Ford, dressage is an oasis. In the stable, he can slip into his riding pants, shed the macho cowboy image, and feel like himself for a change.

For Cleo O'Shea, dressage is a fresh start. She's got a new boarding school, absentee parents, and, best of all, no one to remember her past. . . .

They're an unlikely pair. Cleo's looking for love, but Alex has a secret he's not ready to give up, and a flirtation with Cleo is the last thing on his mind. But you can't find romance before you know real friendship, and sometimes the last person you'd ever think of as a friend ends up being the one you need the most.

If this was a Thoroughbred book, Christina would be having an aneurysm. The whole thing is about dressage, obviously. Alex has been obsessed with it since he was a kid, and Cleo spent her first jumping lesson sobbing. I appreciated that, actually.

The brief rundown is this: we've got two main characters. The book skips around between Alex and Cleo, telling Alex's story in third person and Cleo's story in first person. It sounds a little weird, until you start reading it. They're both sixteen. They both live in Nanaimo on Vancouver Island, Alex because he's always lived there and Cleo because she was sent to a girl's boarding school centered in equestrian sports. Cleo is filthy rich because her parents are movie producers/directors, and thus leave her alone for vast quantities of time while they're off shooting movies in exotic locales. Alex's mom abandoned his family and his dad is a budding alcoholic living in an RV in front of their house. He's got an aunt and two sisters, twins, making sure things get done rather slowly around the house as Alex's dad spends all his time sleeping with a balding woman who is the island's most prolific realtor because her face is most commonly seen plastered all over areas destined to become strip malls.

Of course, they've got problems. Alex is struggling with his sexuality, which is to say he's a sixteen-year-old gay kid and horrified by the idea of having to tell anyone. Cleo is rich and selfish and lazy, but she's also dealing with the fact that her parents basically dumped her in Vancouver when her actions lead to their massive house in L.A. being stripped of all its expensive televisions, vases, and other possessions. She has no friends, and because she rides dressage and most of the girls at the school don't, that leaves her with one other girl who is a friend by proximity.

They both have horses. Cleo's parents bought her a ridiculously expensive and talented mare called Tandava. Alex has an elderly paint named Turnip that his dad won in a poker game. In a twist of fate, they both start training with Ivan and Fergus, dressage coaches recently retired to the area. Initially Cleo is interested in Alex, but when she tries to kiss him he just winds up screaming "gay!" at her.

And other things happen. I'm actually not inclined to spoil this book, because it's actually good. In the many books I've read for this blog (sure, many of them were Thoroughbred books, but they damn well count) I have learned that stumbling across a good horse-themed book is a miracle, so I'm treasuring this moment. Another Kind of Cowboy is a fun story. It's well-written and the characters are hilarious in a realistic way. It even makes dressage sound interesting. You'll probably like it. So run over to the library or the bookstore and grab a copy. Posthaste. As in now. Go.

Aug 25, 2008

You can't tame what wants to run into a tornado and die.

Taming the Star Runner
by S.E. Hinton

As requested by Kerry, I decided to pick up Taming the Star Runner. It's by S.E. Hinton, who is using the ever popular replace your first name with initials so readers won't know you're a woman method, because little boys everywhere are too afraid to pick up books written by women because it's not manly to read books written by women. What's with that, little boys?

Well, anyway. You too can request a book for us to read. It's very simple. Just run over to the requests page and ask away to your heart's delight. We're slowly, but surely, trying to comply with the demand here at the Whitebrook Farm Blog.
Travis is the epitome of cool, especially when he's in trouble. But when he's sent to stay on his uncle's ranch, he finds that his tough attitude doesn't make him any friends and his city survival skills are no match for the unforgiving land around him.

He does find friendship of a sort with Casey, who runs a riding school at the ranch. She's the bravest person Travis has ever met. She's crazy enough to try to tame the Star Runner, her beautiful, dangerous horse that's always on edge, about to explode. It's clear to Travis that he and the Star Runner are two of a kind -- wild creatures not meant to be tamed.
This blurb is going along normally until that last sentence, when whoever wrote this summary decided to smack me in the face with the very obvious fact that the Star Runner and Travis are two of a kind. Hey, summary writer, I kind of got that to begin with. You could have said something else instead, like, how Travis learns that it's not okay to be a narcissistic asshole, but no, we just get a promise that he's going to remain "wild" for the entirety of the book.

Okay, everybody, meet Travis. Travis is a troubled sixteen-year-old kid who wants to be the next F. Scott Fitzgerald. Basically, this means that Travis is a prick. Notice how I could have said that Travis aims to rise above his problems and become the next Great American Writer before succumbing to alcohol and then collapsing at a relatively young age. No, Travis is just a prick. You see that "epitome of cool" line at the beginning of the summary? Travis genuinely believes this.

So the deal here is that Travis has this stepfather, Stan. Stan is your typical evil stepparent. He slaps around Travis's mom, refuses to have any photo of Travis's dead dad in the house, and randomly burned some of Travis's manuscripts because he thought it was clutter and, of course, you burn clutter. In front of your stepson. Of course you do. So, unnaturally evil Stan basically sets himself up for a fight, and Travis doesn't hold back, which lands him in jail. When he gets out, his mom decides to defuse the situation by sending Travis to her dead husband's brother's ranch in Oklahoma for the school year.

In Oklahoma, Travis is plagued by suddenly not being cool and not being able to drink whiskey at home. Life is so, so hard. He's also forced to hang out with girls all the time, because Ken, the uncle, has a barn that he leases out to Casey, our resident horse loving girl. Casey is trying to figure out this Star Runner horse, who is not wild so much as mean. Travis describes Casey as good-looking, if she were a guy. I don't know what to take from this. There's also a hoard of other girls -- Kristen, Kelsey, Jennifer, and Robyn. Jennifer is the pretty one, and Robyn is the insane "fat one." By insane, I mean she spends most of her time snorting coke and walking around shirtless because she's "good at taking her clothes off" because she's been strip searched so often.

So the book continues on about how Travis thinks he's cool and how everyone in Oklahoma doesn't understand his coolness. Then he gets the notice that his book is being accepted by a publisher, and he decides it's time to party until he gets sick. Being sixteen, this would be a problem. Fortunately for Travis, Ken keeps some Crown Royal around and he more or less downs that and manages to slip unnoticed into a bar that you get the distinct impression isn't cool enough for Travis (at least, according to him). Only then the owner finds out he's not 21 and flips out and fires the bouncer and the bouncer kicks the living crap out of Travis. All the while Travis is drunk and convinced that he'd be able to "take" the bouncer if he was not drunk. However, seeing as how I once worked with a bouncer, I really highly...HIGHLY...doubt that this is possible. I also dislike this whole scene. Sure, no one likes underage kids in bars because mainly they're annoying, but no owner is going to flip out to that degree. Just escort the kid to the sidewalk and get on with your life. Who the hell cares?

Anyway, Ken picks Travis up and Travis is all self-important about being drunk while Ken is not impressed. Neither am I, really. Later on, Travis, through his hung over haze, kills a water moccasin and earns Casey's respect in doing so, only then he hears from his mom via phone that evil Stan is up to no good and wants to read Travis's book before they sign any contracts. You see, he wants to make sure he's not in the book. Travis flips and throws the phone, narrowly missing Ken's toddler. Ken briefly thinks about kicking Travis out because Ken's soon-to-be-ex-wife doesn't like it when phones are thrown at her toddler. Travis cries, and all is well because when main characters cry everyone seems to magically understand their plight.

At this point, the editor from the publishing house comes along and gets Travis talking about books and reading and whoa if that wasn't fun for Travis and boring for me. Travis admits that he tried to read a book by F. Scott Fitzgerald that involved sipping sherry and he didn't get it, giving all readers a chance to feel superior to Travis. The editor talks about cleaning up the language in his book a little and end scene. Travis skips along, thrilled that he's being published. His mom takes back what Stan said about reading the book, and all is well.

But then there's this horse show that goes on and on forever. The Star Runner dumps Casey and she cracks a rib, but rides the next day and wins, of course. Travis takes this opportunity to kiss her, because he randomly fell in love with her after he decided she was good-looking if she was a guy. Casey discourages any relationship, but acknowledges that Travis somehow knows her better than anyone. They are so alike...and...stuff.

Now, apparently Travis left a bit of a power vacuum back in whatever dirty city he came from and his friends fell in with this guy named Orson, who had them all robbing houses. He discovers this after the horse show when Joe, random dirty city friend, calls him up from the local gas station to inform Travis that he hitch hiked all the way to Oklahoma and had to jump out of a moving vehicle when the driver started to get a little squirrelly. Travis and Casey pick him up and Travis breaks out the Crown Royal and Joe tells his sob story about how Orson, "the twins" and he were robbing houses. Only the twins did a job by themselves without giving Orson anything, and Orson went insane and shot them point blank. In the head. With a twenty-two. Ken, being a lawyer, dumps Joe off with the authorities and they all drive back home in what appears to be one of those massive storms I so anxiously remember back when I used to live in tornado alley.

So this tornado comes along and they try to get the horses in, only the Star Runner gets out of his paddock. So Casey and Travis jump in her car and try to chase the Star Runner down. In so doing they very vaguely drive straight into the tornado. I guess the Star Runner gets away, or maybe dies, or something. S.E. Hinton got heavy on the melodrama at the end, so who knows. There was some reference to burning flesh, and Travis is deaf for a few days, and Casey is fine, but no longer interested in Travis, so Travis transfers his affection to Jennifer and starts to write his next book.
  • They were flying, skimming the road, the Central guys left behind long ago, and nobody, man, nobody thought he'd get the car back down. Here, Travis oohs and ahhs us with his fantastic drag racing abilities while chugging beer. I guess they're going 115 and there's some question about if they can stop? I don't know. Maybe it's just me, but there are three ways you can get the car "back down." 1. Take your foot off the gas pedal. 2. Even more efficient, step on the break. 3. Probably less efficient, but no less effective, crash the car. All three work.
  • Travis combed his hair, staring into the mirror with fixed concentration. He was good-looking. Probably one of the best-looking guys in the school. He had dark brown hair, not so long that he looked like one of the dopers, not so short that he looked like one of the straights, the student council preppies. Five foot eight. Not bad for sixteen, and by the size of his hands and feet he hadn't stopped growing yet. Good eyes. Great eyes, actually. Gray-green and as cool as the Irish sea. He had read a book about F. Scott Fitzgerald once, and it said he had eyes as cold as the Irish sea. Travis liked that. He secretly liked his eyelashes, too, a black fringe, as long as a girl's. He had a good build, long-boned and lean and flat-stomached, and that was the reason he liked tight T-shirts. Kirk was taller, and had broader shoulders, but Travis thought his own build was as good as any in the school. A lot of girls thought so. A lot. I love this paragraph, so I had to transcribe it here in all its glory. I laughed, and laughed, and, oh, I laughed again.
  • On the plane, Travis takes his cat with him into the cabin and the guy next to him states his displeasure. Travis? "Yeah, well, I hear a lot of faggots hate cats."
  • Because Travis isn't popular at his new school (believe me, this is like the end of the world for him) he takes to smoking cigarettes unnoticed on the baseball field or "in the library." Call me crazy, but I think someone would notice if you were smoking in the library.
  • These damn suckers were making him doubt his looks. Travis notices, to his horror, that he has round ears and a pale face. He tries desperately to remember that he is a modern day Adonis...and I laugh and laugh some more.
  • "You must dress like your characters." She had it backward, his characters dressed like he did. Yeah, we in the business of being critical because we can call that self-insertion.
  • The editor asks Travis who he thinks would read his book and he replies: "Teenagers. Kids like me." He was sure they would because he'd read it and loved it. The fact that he's the author of said book has no bearing on this at all, I'm sure.
  • At one of Casey's horse shows, in which Travis accompanies her as a groom, he discovers that the rest of the girls (as, apparently, only girls ride horses at horse shows) think he looks like a "sleazy punk." Horrified, again, he runs to a mirror. Again. What does he tell himself? His hair is too long to look punk! What do hicks know anyway? He's so cool at home! Which is Cleveland, by the way. So...I wouldn't throw stones, Travis. I really wouldn't.
  • S.E. Hinton is obsessed with K's and hard C's. The names in this book: Kirk, Ken, Christopher, Kristen, Kelsey, Ms. Carmichael, Katherine Caroline Kencaide (Casey).
  • We get a lot of unwarranted comparisons between Ken and Achilles. Yes, Achilles from Greek mythology. I'm not sure where this comes from, especially since it's supposed to draw out this line of thought that Ken was young and pushed the envelope too when he was 16 and is now 37 (which means he is old) so he is therefore supposed to be the mentor to Travis's what? Patroclus? I really don't understand how Achilles could be anyone's mentor. He was insane. You know, with the rage?
Okay, the only reason I sort of liked this book is because I had the impression that S.E. Hinton was making fun of Travis along with me. Otherwise, I really wanted someone to walk up to Travis and kick him in the groin. Repeatedly.

Although, perhaps she's not making fun of him because, from her website:
S.E. Hinton on the book:
Taming The Star-Runner is a horse story, a love story, and a story of the different forms art can take. And some of the things that happen to Travis, who wrote his first book at sixteen, happened to me. But not all, Thank God.
Well, take from that what you will.

(In light of some pretty crazy rabid Taming the Star Runner fans -- who knew, right? -- I regret to inform you all that commenting on this post is now closed. If you want to take issue with my opinion, e-mail me. I know, I know, making anonymous, misspelled comments is cute and fun for everyone, but this is getting a little weird.)

Aug 21, 2008

That Bonnie could never be trusted.

The Betrayal of Bonnie
by Barbara van Tuyl
Published: 1975

My friends, we have reached the end for Bonnie and Julie. I know it's hard to accept, but in time I feel we'll all be able to move on and lead fulfilling lives.

Racing Luck

Bonnie just had to win the Marquesa Stakes and make her racing comeback. Everyone said she was good enough to do it. And it would mean everything to Bonnie's owner, Julie Jefferson, lying in a hospital bed after a cruel accident at the track. Yet Bonnie's return to her remarkable winning form did not end the run of bad luck for Julie and her trainer Monty Everett. For Bonnie was showing up positive in the track tests for drugs, and that meant trouble with a capital T! After all, what good was winning if you were accused of cheating and barred from racing?

But who would dope Bonnie? And how could the Deepwater crew catch the culprit and put Monty and Bonnie back in racing again...?


Well, I am remarkably less enthused about this installment. I think it's possibly because it's finally gotten on my last nerve that everyone loves Julie Jefferson to the point of worshiping at her feet. Also, Julie pulls a bit of a Cindy McLean in this book, and as we all know that's enough to set me on edge. Give me another seriously injured girl who won't shut up about winning races/seeing races/assisting the super special horse that needs her sublime presence and won't listen to medical advice to the point that she finds herself half-paralyzed and sprawled on a hospital floor...and I don't know what I will do. Probably start weeping as I hold the book to an open flame. Yeah...something melodramatic like that.

So, as we all know from several previous installments, Bonnie is the best racing filly that ever was. Julie is the most loved girl in horse racing, if not the world. Bonnie, however, has suffered some horrible luck and as a result got injured, suffered through some crazy breeding adventure, gave birth to twins, and is now back on the track looking at a come back. Everyone is thrilled except for Monty, who is simply cautiously optimistic. Monty is awesome, I have decided. He's really the only one who acts like he has a brain.

The book opens up with exercising Bonnie, and I guess she's training so well that Monty starts mentioning this Marquesa Stakes thing and this somehow leads him to a pancake house with Julie. They eat pancakes. I guess. I don't know...I read that part quite a while ago. I just know that this scene ends during a rainstorm and in the middle of the storm, while they're driving back to the farm, Julie sees "something alive" on the side of the road. Just guess what it is. Guess. I bet you will get it right on the first try.

It's another dog. Someone ran over it (while it was, like, not raining!) and left it to die. Yeah, poor it. I didn't really care all that much because all I was thinking was "Really? Another damned dog?" Monty is kinda thinking the same thing, proof positive for why he's awesome. Unfortunately Julie wears the pants in their non-relationship and insists that they take the dog to this vet and then she comes up with this idea that she'll open an animal shelter at Deepwater Farm and because Mr. T is rich he says sure? Something like that. And she keeps the dog. She names it Barney or something along those lines. She now has a Beagle, a St. Bernard, and this new dog, which is an Irish Wolfhound. How she manages this, I really don't know.

Moving on, Bonnie continues to be fantastic. Everyone exclaims on how fantastic she is. Oh, to be so fantastic! Then Julie kinda sorta gets squished by a crazy run away and injures her back. This is the END OF THE WORLD for everyone, pretty much. Because, as previously stated, Julie is everyone's personal Jesus in these books. So Bonnie's stakes race comes along and by that point there's been this long hospital drama I don't care to get into because there was all of that "but I have to see the race!" and more "like hell you do!" and more "but I really can walk! oh, wait... *collapses*" and then some "well, okay, but as long as you stay in your wheelchair..." and by that point I wanted someone to run a car over her.

But then Bonnie wins! Oh, bliss! She wins her race by seventeen lengths and sets a new track record of 2:01 and something which doesn't impress me. Everyone is thrilled. Only then they have to test her and a couple of days later they are informed that her tests are "cloudy" but not positive...so, yeah. Monty screams a lot and the racing secretary guy just sort of shrugs and since they are "cloudy" they are not disqualified? Well, whatever. It doesn't really matter because this means Julie has to immediately ask Monty why he did it. Wow, that's friendship for you.

Monty is suitably crushed. The girl he loves and wants to marry instantly suspects him of doping her equine soul mate. What is a boy to do? So everyone finally gets over Julie's super shininess to tell her she was being a bitch to Monty, and she's still determined to blame him because she figures he couldn't handle seeing her disappointed or some such.

Now, granted, Monty has been treating her like glass for five books now. I understand Julie's frustration because she's something like 22 at this point and I imagine she just wants to have sex already. Monty still sees her as a child, but really, it's just ridiculous. So then Julie finally realizes that this can't possibly be right. Monty wouldn't do such a thing because he's awesome.

So another race comes along. Bonnie wins by eleven or twelve lengths or something. She comes back with another positive test. Monty freaks again. Julie freaks. Everyone freaks. What's more, Monty gets suspended so they have to move Bonnie off to another trainer. Mr. T is NOT HAPPY. But because he's rich and therefore powerful, he pushes his weight around and gets Bonnie put in a stable to herself with 24/7 guard so she'll be under watch constantly. It is, theoretically, impossible for this horse to be tampered with. So what happens? Yeah, she comes back from another race (she wins it by ten lengths) and has yet another positive result. All hell breaks loose because at this point they're all questioning each other and so forth.

Mr. T has had it. He's ready to pull Bonnie off the track. But then someone comes up with the idea to send Bonnie to Cornell. Because they have some fancy lab equipment that they can put to use testing their horse to see if she'll randomly test positive for amphetamines. As it turns out, she does. So apparently she's just special and producing her own steroids? Well, whatever is happening, Bonnie is the source of all the drama because her metabolism changed after her pregnancy and no matter what she'll keep spitting out false positives.

I have no idea if this is possible. With people, kidney and liver disease will give you a false positive for amphetamines...as well as diabetes...but I don't know how this works for horses. I have no interest in finding out, either. As it happens.

Anyway, everyone is happy. Monty finally asks Julie to marry him and she says yes.

  • Monty is as "hopelessly tongue-tied as a bashful lad out of the summer of 1875." Were lads especially bashful in the summer of 1875, or is this a reference I'm not catching?
  • "The other boys would have loved to beat [Sunbonnet]. I know for a fact the boy on Ruby Frump bet a bundle on [Sunbonnet]..." Yeah, that's not possible. Jockeys can only bet races through the owner of the horse they're riding, only on the horse they're riding, and only to win. Also, who names a horse Ruby Frump?
So, there's nothing else to say. Except that I think I'm going to try out a Nancy Drew book called The Riding Club Crime next. I may have been tempted to read it solely because the cover depicts a girl and horse falling over Niagara Falls. I couldn't help wondering how they get out of that one.

Aug 18, 2008

Genuine Risk



Genuine Risk
1977-2008

Typically, we're all books all the time here, but you can't ignore Genuine Risk. She was basically our Wonder, after all.

The oldest Kentucky Derby winner is now Alysheba.