Jul 17, 2008

Blind Beauty: bringing the crazy back to horse stories.

Blind Beauty
by K.M. Peyton
Published: 1999

I didn't really know what I was getting into with this book when I picked it up. To me it was just a young adult book with a horse on the cover, so I mindlessly added it to the stack of books I already had and checked them all out. This one is on the long side -- 360 pages -- but I'm pretty sure it could have been cut down severely to get the whole story in. But that would have meant deleting all the exclamatory sentences that come out of nowhere, and as we all know, you can't just do that in horse stories because that takes away most of the completely insane emotional turmoil our characters have to go through. God forbid. Anyway.

Tessa has major attitude and an impossible dream—not a great combination for success. But she believes that fate has delivered the ungainly horse Buffoon to her, and Tessa is determined never to be separated from him. What's more, she intends to one day become a jockey and ride Buffoon in the Grand National. But how can a girl with a violent temper and a “can't do” philosophy gain the physical strength, courage, and money needed to become a jockey—especially when her stepfather would like nothing better than to see her fail? Determination and grit may not be enough—but Tessa's not going to let go without giving it her all.
Okay, the thing about this book is that you can see how it clearly could be good. It really had the potential. Unfortunately it took that potential and then sort of shoved it into the 1960's and decided that "major attitude" could very well mean "homicidal tendencies." Who can tell the difference, right? I'll get to that part later, because it's really the absolute best part.

So, much to my extreme vexation, this book starts out in Ireland. I made a promise to myself that I wasn't going to read another book set in Ireland for at least twelve months, and I just about had to shut it down after the first chapter because the first character we hear about is named Declan. It was almost too much. However, I soldiered on. Declan was having a tough time, mainly because his only mare just gave birth to a filly with no eyes. His wife wants to put the foal down immediately, but since the mare is so old and has this fantastic progeny record, he refuses and keeps the foal. They name this horse Shiner.

Speed up to four years down the line. Declan has become a drunk and his wife left him, taking their eight-year-old daughter, Tessa, with her to Liverpool (thank GOD, we've moved to England and therefore I can now enjoy this book). Declan's bred Shiner, producing a ugly colt that Shiner immediately feels like killing. So Declan saves the colt and feels like getting drunk again because his life sucks. Blah blah blah.

Speed forward another four years. Tessa is now twelve and her mother has remarried to this rich guy called Maurice. Maurice, we are very casually informed, is evil. He likes to run over hedgehogs in his spare time and is just, well, evil. I don't know why, but we are repeatedly informed that he's a jackass and he sort of acts like a jackass sometimes because he wants Tessa in a boarding school because he's tired of her and I don't blame him. Fresh out of getting kicked out of her third boarding school, Tessa comes home and muses to herself about how much she'd like to poison Maurice. She even went so far as to buy arsenic or something, so she could do it slowly, over time, and laugh as he dies. This homicidal rage is chalked up as feisty attitude by the author, who somehow thinks her character should be allowed to physically harm anyone she wants because her stepfather is a jerk. Really, I'm not exaggerating. Cross Tessa and she's not going to fantasize about cutting you. She will cut you and then laugh while you bleed to death.

So she comes home and immediately breaks into some of the sherry, raging about how she hates everything and everyone. She hates her stepbrother for being annoying, she hates her mother for being stupid and staying with Maurice, she hates Maurice, she hates school, etc. She has no friends, because she probably tried to kill anyone who attempted to befriend her. She's scary, actually.

Anyway, Maurice is all pissed off because he can't get her into another school, but since it's almost summer he just decides to get her a job and out of his hair. So he shoves her to some tenants who deal with horses and she hates that. She goes, hates everyone, informs them all that she hates her stepfather (repeatedly) and then rages some more about how she hates them all. She's determined to get fired from the job, but no one will do it so she just hates them even more. If I read the word "hate" one more time I was going to put down the book. Unfortunately for me these people get a fresh group of horses in and Tessa is given the ugliest of the bunch to look after. Enraged that she has to deal with this ugly horse, Tessa informs the horse that she hates it (sigh) and that it's ugly as sin and she wants nothing to do with him. The horse, aptly named Buffoon, just sort of looks at her, and then she starts crying. I feel absolutely nothing for her. In fact, I'm happy she's crying at this point because that means she's not trying to kill someone. Then she finds out that the horse is out of Shiner and she goes from hating it to loving it in about two seconds flat and starts doing an impressive version of Cindy McLean...if Cindy had been homicidal.

Anyway, she gets shoved into another school and Tessa is so pissed off she's determined to be expelled and she does this by shoving food in this bulky girl's face and then pulling a knife to defend herself against any revenge food attacks. Seriously. So she's expelled. Yay Tessa. She goes skipping off to the farm again so she can learn to ride Buffoon. There's some screaming about how Buffoon is really hers and how dare anyone inform her that he's actually owned by someone else, and then Buffoon miraculously becomes Wonder's Champion and beats all the other horses in a work with Tessa aboard, doing her best Cindy impression. It's awful. Really, just makes you want to gouge out your eyes. But Tessa is "a natural" and therefore we're supposed to think this is possible. Not to mention this is steeplechasing. Do we spend any time on Tessa learning to jump? Nope. She just does it. But then the book is helped out in this area by skipping another four years. We'll just assume she learned to jump somewhere in there.

So four years go by. Tessa is now sixteen and ready to race ride. Her first race she falls and breaks her wrist. Poor her. Then Buffoon has suddenly become so good in the last four years that he's ready for the Grand National, only just before the race someone steals his magical pony friend! Gasp! So Tessa just knows Maurice is the one that stole the pony, which is so earth shattering that Buffoon refuses to eat, and so she runs over to the mansion and brandishes a knife at anything that moves. Her mother calms her down, and they go to the Grand National and they, like, come in fifth. They're all thrilled, and Tessa's dad shows up, but is all drunk and just randomly walks off. So that was her wonderful father-daughter moment. Tessa goes home, has dinner with her wonderfully loving family, and winds up throwing food at her stepfather and storms out back to the farm. However, on her way to the farm she discovers the pony stabled on her stepfather's property, and overcome with more rage, she runs straight back to the mansion, grabs a carving knife, and stabs Maurice in the chest with it.

Yeah, so our lovely main character attempts to kill her stepfather, gets put away until she's 18, and Buffoon gets sold because his owner dies, and Maurice lives because Tessa is a weakling and didn't stab him harder or enough. In the chest. With a knife.

So, Tessa's all forlorn that she didn't kill Maurice. Then her jockey friend, Tom, visits her and he finds Buffoon and she gets out of jail/the insane asylum, and is all forlorn again because Buffoon has cataracts. So she gets her mom to give her money for cataract surgery for the horse and then he can see again and Maurice beats up her mom when he finds out, so her mom leaves him and starts to have sex with this other guy who's actually nice and they go to the Grand National again and she rides Buffoon and they of course win. (That was the last half of the book, for anyone wondering.) And Tessa and Tom kiss, because there was this whole "can she love anyone besides a horse" plot strung around in there. And I think she's, like, 22 by the end of the book. I'm pretty sure there was another four year skip in time, but I was wasn't paying close enough attention. That whole bloody incident midway through kinda derailed me.

Points:
  • While I was reading this thing, I kept convincing myself it couldn't have possibly been published in 1999. Really, it reads like it was published in 1960.
  • Whenever they talk about a horse being put down, they always say the horse is going to be shot. Again, I couldn't help thinking...1999? What? Are the English still shooting horses when they break down on racetracks, or is this just something they say? Are they delightfully clinging to old phrases or what?
  • At one point one of the other exercise boys says something remarkably true and yet not totally positive about Buffoon and Tessa throws a curry comb at his head and cuts up his cheek. Everyone remarks that Tessa should really grow up. Yeah...and here I keep thinking that someone should have noticed the signs.
  • So, Maurice really is sort of evil. But it's in a totally out of nowhere and ridiculous way. Like...his horse doesn't perform well on the track so he wants the trainer to shut it up in its stall without exercise, food, or water for a week. The trainer refuses to do this, so Maurice has the horse shot. Really, yes, this is evil behavior and we're supposed to hate Maurice for this just as much as Tessa does but I don't buy it. It's stupid. It's like what a twelve-year-old fangirl would dream up.
  • Tessa also desperately wants her mother to leave Maurice, but she doesn't ever say this in a positive way. It's just screaming, waving around knives, and yelling. Then she has to remark wildly on why her mother is just so stupid. Supportive! And the thing is, this happens mostly when Tessa is sixteen. So it's obvious someone is still a spoiled brat with no concept of the real world.
  • Also, I must say that the cutesy cursive chapter headings are really out of place in this book.
Amusingly enough, if you go to the Amazon page for this book it gets mostly five stars. I can't decide why this is. Perhaps I'm not giving it a fair shot, but I really could not stand Tessa. While the book improves after she gives up the really unnerving urge to slice people to shreds and bathe in their blood, by the time you get there you feel like you've been through hell and back. I also might be a little irked that I accidentally picked up a book with Irish people involved, but for some reason I think it's more the fact that Tessa is a raging psychopath and the story is the most unrealistic of Thoroughbred plots, only on steroids.

Jul 15, 2008

Watch out! The Arizona Kid is becoming a man.

The Arizona Kid
by Ron Koertge
Published: 1988, 2005

Guys, I'm so excited. This is the first time I get to review a book for this blog in which I get to mention sex, drugs, cursing, alcohol, underage drinking, and gambling! It's like everything our beloved Thoroughbred characters would shrink from in horror while screaming "Unclean! Unclean!" This is precisely why I loved it. I mean, sure, I have a huge soft spot in my heart for our darling girls with their emotionally and physically stunted mindsets, but you can only take so much, you know?

From the moment sixteen-year-old Billy steps off the train in Tucson, he knows this will be a summer unlike any he's seen in small-town Bradleyville, Missouri. For starters, he's staying with his cool gay uncle, who has managed to get him a job at the racetrack caring for horses. Still, Billy doesn't expect the horseracing world to be quite as rough and tumble as this — toiling side by side with a macho survivalist and falling hard for the feisty, romance-shy "exercise girl" Cara Mae. With his trademark fast-paced dialogue filled with wit and compassion, Ron Koertge tells the tale of an insecure teen who discovers that gaining stature involves more than Stetsons and boots — and that lessons on love and manhood come from the places you least expect.
We've also got a few other firsts thrown in for this blog -- the first male author, the first openly homosexual character, and the first instance of first person narrative. All of which is wildly refreshing. I am positively overflowing with giddiness brought on by new experiences!

Anyhoo, I'll just settle down and get to the book. I've included that The Arizona Kid was first written in 1988, but since it was republished in 2005 certain popular icons were clearly edited out and replaced with more current icons like the Dixie Chicks and Shaq. Who knows what was there previously. Probably Cyndi Lauper and Wilt Chamberlain. The only way you can seriously tell it was written in the late 80's is how the AIDS virus is treated during the entire novel. When AIDS popped up on the screen in 1981 I was an infant, but by the time the freaking out was at a high point I was old enough to remember and get the lectures on how you can and cannot contract HIV. Sitting on toilet seats that were subject to the grime of the general public? Dandy! Spitting on people for no reason? Totally not okay! (Although you'd think spitting would be discouraged in general, my era had to make HIV as easy to contract as Mono, so the message of politeness = not spitting on someone had a more urgent message attached.)

HIV/AIDS is the hot topic of this book mainly because our main character, Billy, is staying with his uncle Wes, who is gay and happens to be going through the emotional turmoil of watching his friends die and attempt to not die from the illness. We'll get to that later. First, to Billy and his problems, which mainly boil down to the fact that he's short and unsure of what he wants to do with himself and a virgin. His parents have him trucked off to Tuscon for the summer, and his uncle Wes has set up a job for him at the local racetrack. Billy thinks he might want to be a vet, hence the racetrack job. Anyway, Billy is kind of awkward starting out and is pretty self-conscious about his height. He even wears vertically striped shirts in an attempt to look taller, which fails time and time again.

Wes is pretty awesome. He's one of those perfect guys that gets hit on by everyone, is apparently a neat freak despite being an artist (perhaps it's just my experience, but artists are never neat freaks), and gets about 80% of the fantastic lines in the book. He knows this Jack guy from his business and sets up Billy's job as one of Jack's grooms. This leads us to the racetrack, where we meet Lew, his girlfriend Abby, and Cara Mae, one of Jack's exercise riders. Lew is one of those guys who thinks World War III is going to break out at any minute, and is totally prepared for the apocalypse at the drop of a hat. His mother is essentially permanently stoned, and his father is insane. No, really. Lew's dad, Edgar, has the astonishing ability to drop down from the ceiling unannounced, start screaming military terminology at the top of his lungs, and then starts to shoot random objects with blanks from his machine gun. I kid you not. Edgar is reason enough to read the book.

Anyway, Billy meets Cara Mae and his teenage boy hormones kick in full force. They sort of get together during night races at the track, where he's helping out with this filly called Moon's Medicine. After the filly loses tremendously, they go out and get some beer and park somewhere. While Lew and Abby basically have sex in the front cab of the truck, Billy and Cara wander off somewhere and get acquainted in a lovely platonic way that ends Billy back at home with his uncle giving him condoms. Best to be prepared! And all that. Wes also gives Billy these boots he doesn't wear (Wes went through some shopping addiction that left him with multitudes of things he doesn't use, all for fear he will get AIDS and die) and Billy buys a Stetson and basically builds his cocoon while he waits to emerge as a fully grown adult male.

Luckily for Billy, it's basically hot as hell in Tuscon, and he offers to take Cara to the water park in the city. Cara is not financially well off, and her swim suit is a little stretched out, offering Billy all sorts of opportunities to develop erections he can be embarrassed by. Somehow he manages to hide all of this and lays the foundation for his relationship with Cara. Meanwhile, Moon's Medicine does much better in her next night race because she's developed a loving relationship with a chicken. Only after the race the resident antagonist, enemy trainer Fletcher, comes and takes her away to his barn because her owners are pricks and jumped ship. This results in a wonderful physical confrontation between Lew, Billy, and Fletcher's muscle named Grif. Grif basically wins, they take the filly, and Cara gets all attentive to Billy. Which equals sex. So Billy gets to put those condoms to use and starts to break out of his cocoon.

Then Moon's Medicine dies. This spins into motion our second half of the book, which pits Fletcher and Grif against Lew and Billy in this plot that seems to come straight out of The Sweet Running Filly and its sequels (that I have not read yet, but this would be right in there, I am sure). Pissed off that he's being blamed for Moon's death, Fletcher gets all confrontational with Lew and Billy, which winds up with them betting on these two new horses. Jack is getting a maiden filly named The Dark Mirage and Fletcher is getting a filly named French Bred (ha ha). So, Lew basically gets them into this stupid bet about which horse will win and there's a thousand dollars at stake. The Dark Mirage is sort of crazy, requiring lots of attention and, as it turns out, watermelon. I don't understand the watermelon, but I guess it's her comfort food or something. Only it doesn't really work well because Billy and Cara just wind up taking her out to this private training facility so she can work in peace.

Meanwhile, Wes is going through the death of one of his friends, gets all drunk, and then has to be tested again for some reason and goes to a gay bar and, you know, Billy takes this all in stride before one of Wes's flamboyant friends hits on him in a most amusing fashion. Which I will now briefly transcribe:
"Who is this macho morsel?"
"I live here."
"This isn't an outfit, is it?" (Strokes Billy's sleeve.) "You've been -- pardon the expression -- working."
"Look, all I want to do is go to bed, okay?"
"I'm yours!"
"Stop handling me, man. I mean it!"
"I love it when they're stern."
It's sort of like a Pepe Le Pew cartoon.

Anyway, then we've got some drama about having to go home in the midst of all this bet business. Billy is angsting over telling Cara he loves her and vice versa, resulting in dramatics and a fight that they get over while he guards The Dark Mirage from any nefarious deeds. Although then Fletcher and Grif show up, totally unprepared for whatever they were going to do. This is probably because Fletcher is drunk. They basically yell a little, Grif manages to get Fletcher back to their truck, and then Cara and Billy have sex in a stall.

The Dark Mirage beats French Bred in their race (although I don't think she wins the race overall), Billy and Cara manage to bring their relationship to a suitable end that may or may not continue past the summer (I mean, come on, they're teenagers, and the book realizes that), Billy decides to come back to the University of Arizona for racetrack management after high school, Cara goes up to Phoenix for another race meet with her dad, and Billy goes home a man.

It is remarkably satisfying, although the very end is sort of plunked down there and feels unexpectedly sudden. Billy is a sweet kid, and his story is pretty amusing. I was a little disappointed in the plot twist halfway through with this bet and how Jack just sort of let Billy and Cara deal with The Dark Mirage. It was like a tarnished Thoroughbred plot, to a certain extent. However, I would still happily recommend the book to anyone.

Jul 13, 2008

If Wishes Were Horses, Nobody Would Ever Walk Again

And now that it seems that my Happy Fun Fire Time Adventure™ is over, and Mitch has been returned to the blissful comforts of home after having been evacuated in the middle of the night nearly two weeks ago (hey, it's drama right out of Melanie's Last Ride!) I have another book review. I know, I know, I swore it would be Shadow Horse, and that's read, and everything, but I'm just having the damnedest time writing the bloody review. I think it's because I sort of liked the book, and am now having trouble even trying to rip it to shreds, but it can't write nice either. It's slow going. So I picked up an old favorite at the library the other day, and thought I'd run a fast review on that since it's a quick and easy read, and the end of the book meshes so well with our Happy Fun Time Fire Adventure™ that it just seems more appropriate. Anyway... enjoy!

If Wishes Were Horses
by Jean Slaughter Doty
Published: October 1984

I grew up with Jean Slaughter Doty books; they had ponies in them, so of course from a very early age, those were the books my parents found at the library for me. Now that I think about it, looking back, I think my parents were trying to prepare me for the future realization that not everything was cookies and cream with horses. Jean Slaughter Doty wrote books that were realistic, brutally frank and blunt at times, without much of the sunshine and rainbows and golden butterfly farts from Magikal Gypsy Vanner asses that's often so prevalent in other horse books. Oh, don't get me wrong, there is a sprinkling of sunshine and rainbows because good things happen, but at the same time, Doty's books have bad things that happen too. Because that's just a fact of life. And sometimes, there is no happily ever after.



I've always really loved the cover of If Wishes Were Horses (the hardback at least, it's the only copy I've ever seen, so I don't know if there are different covers) because it was just very well done. It sort of had a watercolor feel to it; like paint daubs in Photoshop, which I always liked. The detail is there, but it's not such needle-sharp detail that it spoils the big picture; and the two little chestnut fillies running on the cover around the two girls is just very balanced and cute. They're such teeny-tiny foals, but I love their color and chrome. They're how I imagine Secretariat looked as a baby, only gallon-sized rather than pint-sized. ☺
Thirteen-year-old Stephany Reed has grown up on Thunder Rock Farm, where for many years her family has bred and raised Thoroughbred racehorses. And in the last few months since her father's death, she and her older sister, Camilla, have kept the farm going on their own.

Caring for the broodmares and stallions and the newborn foals is hard work but satisfying, and the two girls begin to hope that they will be able to pay off the debts that threaten Thunder Rock's future. Then suddenly, disaster strikes, endangering the very lives of the horses they love...
My only gripe is that Doty seems to have gone the Mary Sue route, and chosen the more (shall we say) exotic pronunciation of Stephanie and Camilla has a very high-minded name, but I guess the Reeds could have gotten away with it being monied-rich and all. But other than that, I've got no issues. It's not sunshine and rainbows and magikal butterfly farts -- they've got to pay off their debts or it's bye-bye "happily ever after."

Set in the Virginia countryside, If Wishes Were Horses begins on a dark stormy night at 3 A.M when Stephany awakens in the barn office at a phone call from Jimmy Connor, the next door neighbor. As an interesting bit of back story, Jimmy grew up with beef cattle, but decided horses were a lot cooler (and probably didn't shit and eat as much) than cattle, so the minute his folks took off for that big retirement place everyone goes to (Arizona, who'da thunk... why do people retire to Arizona anyway? It's hot there in the summer.) Jimmy ditched the critters that moo and picked up critters that neighed. So he's a racehorse trainer, and after giving Stephany some grief about her older sister being at a dance and not at home, he demands a horse. And it's funny how he demands it, so I'll quote it:
"Then you have to help me. I need a horse. Right away."

I sighed. "Jimmy, you know we've got all kinds of horses. What particular horse have you got in mind? What kind of a horse is a three-o'clock-in-the-morning horse?"

"The mare. The tall gray one with the ears."
That mare turns out to be Rosie, and we're treated to a trip down Memory Lane with Stephany. Rosie, being registered as Roses Red, with Bold Ruler on top, and Mahmoud on the bottom, you'd think she'd be a hell of a racehorse. But nah, she can't outrun a fat man going downhill, and thus becomes the perfect playtoy for two girls growing up on a racehorse farm, when they've been forbidden from going near the racehorses. That bit always kind of struck me as surprising, maybe because I got used to the Thoroughbred series afterwards where kids were expected to pitch in and help, but looking back, maybe it makes sense -- the racehorses were the business, and Rosie was the toy.

So anyway, Jimmy needs Rosie for some mysterious errand, and Stephany says she'll have her ready as soon as he runs his van over. She then goes to look in on the three mares in foal, two outside mares -- one being a daughter of Secretariat -- and their Princequillo mare, Pamela who is the only mare they own that's in foal. And then she wraps Rosie's legs, while giving us another trip down Memory Lane about how everything went to shit so easily. That back when both the Reed parents were alive, everything was swell -- they were rich, they were happy, their horses were selling. And then Mumsy kicked the bucket without warning, and Dear Daddy sort of lost the will to live, so the girls closed down the house as more of their servants were leaving, and eventually everything started going to pot in a social sense. But hey, as long as they had the horses, life was jolly, because they never failed to take care of the horses, even if there was dust a foot thick on the stairway banisters.

Well, as long as they were rich too. But when that started tickling away, because Daddy Dear, started selling some of the best broodmares cheap, and sending other mares to crapass studs who couldn't produce their way out of a feed bag, which sort of then means that the foals were shit, so nobody really wanted to buy them. So of course the farm hit some financial upheaval. And then they got lucky with a racehorse they named Glory Now, who was out of the super mare, Pamela, but had a shitass sire. And despite this, he managed to look impressive enough that Mr. Reed decides to hold on to him, thinking they'll make the Derby with him.

We then continue our trip down Stephany's Memory Lane with the saga of Glory Now, who managed to pull a Smarty Jones (or a Bold Ruler) and nearly kill himself before he even made it into racing. So he had to sit out most of the big two-year-old races, but managed to look impressive enough in slow workouts that on slow news days when there was nothing to write about, the farm got some publicity. And Glory Now is apparently a poser, a wanna-be celebrity who looked hot in the morning, but threw a clunker in the afternoon. Nevertheless, he manages to win his maiden race at first asking, beating a bunch of worn-out tired nobodies. But then Jimmy tells Cam and Stephany that "that fancy colt can't run fast enough to keep himself warm" and warns the girls that he needs to tell their dad that Glory Now is a bunch of junk (can we say overhyped!) Glory Now solves the problem neatly by getting one of those 24-hour colic issues that is resolved thanks to quick intervention of the vets, but it's all Jimmy needs to send the colt back to the farm, with the possiblity of "racing next year." (You know, the kind of excuses that racehorse owners these days give for retiring their horses as stallion prospects -- Doty was amazingly ahead of her time!)

So then Things Just Get Worse.™ Papa Reed hasn't sent many -- if any -- mares to any stallions, so the farm is looking at a dry year, and Cam decides not to go back to college so she can stay and run the farm. The farm continues to slide, and Cam even has to take a part-time job. Glory Now looks good, and Dad Reed continues to hold out hope. But then his heart gives out, and the girls are left orphans with a farm, and horses, and mounting debts. So much for life insurance!

And thus, we return to the present, when Jimmy arrives with his van, and whisks Rosie off on her mysterious middle-of-the-early-morning journey, and Stephany goes to check on the mares only to realize that "Oh shit!" the chestnut mare is foaling! And she's all alone. But then Cam arrives, and the girls get to work. In Doty's blunt way, she details what's going on with the foal, and doesn't really mince words. Yes, they have to stick their arm up the back end of the mare, she's blunt and honest about that. But anyway, it turns out the mare is having twins! What! Nobody bothered to y'know, ultrasound her or palpate her before she arrived at the farm? I really kind of blame the owners there, rather than Cam or Stephany, and I suppose it's entirely possible that even with ultrasound, one wouldn't know the mare was carrying twins. But the girls foal her out; pretty graphically detailed birth scene from Doty (the only other one I remember her writing about was Mokey foaling in Winter Pony) and both foals are born. One filly is quickly on her feet, but the weaker one seems to have flipped the proverbial bird at the world, and is just lying there, trying to die or something. It's not really sunshine and rainbows for the two girls because it turns out the other two mares are also foaling, and the brown mare is freaked out at her foal. Bully! So they resort to restraining her long enough to get her foal to nurse, and then it's back to the twin foals to try and get the weaker one to nurse. The weaker foal is kind of having a rough life, but Stephany feeds her, and she goes to sleep, but Stephany freaks out like ninja thinking she was dead.

The vet finally comes, and everyone is OK, although Cam has to report that she called the mare's owners who were really really pissed off that she had twins, and felt that the weaker one should have died. Well, clearly those absentee owners are more concerned about the money (bit of advice for them: Make sure the mare's next foal is not part of a twin-set, mmkay.) But the girls have a chance to relax, and Cam tells Stephany about the dance, and her sort-of-boyfriend Cliff. Cliff is apparently your typical young wealthy scion; fast cars, good-looking and shallow. And he wants to shag Cam. But his selfishness pisses her off, and she pretty much tries to ditch the box of orchids he sends. But Cam shouldn't get too mad at him, who knows, she might need him in the future.

As it turns out, the bank has sent a final warning. Foreclosure is imminent. And it's not enough that they're taking the farm too; the horses are all going to go bye-bye too. So Camilla heads to the bank. The banker is a long-time friend of their father, surely he'll understand! Won't he? (Or is he going to make Cam doing something really sleezy in exchange?) And well, Mr. Banker is a douchebag. Really. I mean, he was all happy to party with the family when they threw their pre-yearling sales shindings, and sit in their box at the racetrack during big races, but now that they're poor ... he's gonna fugdabouit, and demand they pay up ... OR ELSE!

And then the suits come; the people from the bank. And poor Stephany is home alone for it. And they're rich, and don't want to walk in the mud. So they act cold, and mean and stuff. Boo! And poor Stephany is home alone again two days later when the bloodstock agents arrive. But at least these guys aren't jerks, they walk in the mud, and look at the twin fillies and act all shiny and happy. But they do of course, appraise the value of the Thunder Rock horses, and then point out that one is missing! Gasp! It's Rosie, and wherever can she be? Luckily, Stephany remembers a Christmas morning a few years ago, and sneers at the bloodstock agents, because Rosie is belongs to the girls, and not the farm, so therefore, she can keep Rosie. Of course, the bloodstock guys aren't jerks, so they seem nice about this, and one man says it's nice if they could keep her, since they're losing everything else.

Cam goes off to see the family attorney, and it seems that Mr. Lawyer is kind of skeevy because he tries to feel Cam up each chance he gets during this lunch meeting (and him a married man!) and Cam nearly takes his hand off before she tells him to get lost. But good things happen because Rosie is home, and Cam and Jimmy go off to dinner. But good things do not last, because the fire alarm goes ape-shit, and Stephany is home alone. Woe! She has to get the mares out of the barn, and other horses too. Glory Now tries to rip her face off, and she gets his door open, and moves along. She gets the farm's last stallion out, and he tears off into the night. And at last the fire engine arrives, and Cam and Jimmy.

And because this is not a sunshine and rainbows book, four horses have died from smoke inhalation, and one of them turns out to be Glory Now. Stephany goes off to look for Rondelay, the stallion, and finds that he got into the broodmare pasture, so he's clearly in seventh heaven with his harem. Jimmy takes in the horses, and has paid special attention to Rosie. The bank sends a fire inspector and an insurance agent who practically accuse Stephany of smoking in the hay, and that it was all a set-up. Cam goes ballistic on them, and thus they must sheepishly admit that the fire started in the tack room, and could thus be ruled out as an accident.

Cliff calls, and tries to get some loving from Cam by sweeping her off to an island in the Caribbean. She tells him to fuck off in a nice way, and goes back to work. The broodmare barn is reopened, and Dr. Bailey, the vet, comes to check horses, and tell the girls that he's bought the twin fillies. And the bank sale happens, and horses are sold. Good-bye, farewell, no happily ever afters. And Cam sends Stephany out on a ride with Rosie, and Stephany brings her over to Jimmy's barn where she will now live.

The girls get an apartment in town, Stephany gets a job working with Jimmy's yearlings, and life goes on. And then at last, a brief bit of wonderful news! It seems that an exceptional racehorse by Northern Dancer was recently killed following his syndication in Europe. He went nuts on the plane, and they had to put him down. And Jimmy reveals that he had connections with the colt's syndicate, and they needed a test mare for him. And thus, we learn of his mysterious reason for taking Rosie on a journey. And the best news is, she's in foal! Hurrah! And Cam and Jimmy leave the resturant holding hands, double hurrah!

Points of Interest:
  • Doty seems to namedrop a lot with famous racehorses. Thunder Rock is foaling out a Secretariat daughter, they own a daughter of Princequillo, Rosie has Bold Ruler anfd Mahmoud in her pedigree, Rosie was bred to a son of Northern Dancer, Rondelay is a son of Round Table, and there's a yearling son of Sir Ivor on the property.
  • Cam and Stephany really economize when they're forced to. They close up all of the barns on the property except for the main one. They live in small maid's rooms off the kitchen, and let the rest of the house go.
  • Rosie has floppy ears and makes popping noises with her lips. I think that's cute. An old arthritic mare at our barn flaps her lower lip which is really droopy, and makes popping noises.
  • There's a major emphasis on the fact that Thunder Rock is a Thoroughbred breeding farm, and that like many farms that breed to race, while they might start yearlings under saddle there, the majority of the training takes place at the race track. Which is very typical of the racing world.
  • Thunder Rock's silks are blue and white. And the farm is in Virginia. Hmm. Meadow Stable, anyone? The way Cam took over running the place does remind me of the way Penny Chenery took over running Meadow Stable from her ailing father.
  • Doty seems to make a point that Glory Now is absolutely a morning glory horse; that he runs amazingly well in the mornings, but can't make up the ground in the afternoons. And that one personal unrealistically believes in him, but everyone else is more practical.
  • At least Glory Now is a media hype, and Doty isn't afraid to make him into a pathetic racehorse.
So there we have If Wishes Were Horses. I've always loved the book. Maybe because it wasn't sunshines and rainbows and butterflies. Yeah, there was a barn fire, and yeah, the bank foreclosed on the farm and the two girls lost everything -- their parents, and their home and their horses -- but they still had each other, and it looks like they have Jimmy (well, Cam does anyway) and Rosie, and Rosie's going to have a once-in-a-lifetime foal. It's not really a happy ending because a happy ending would have somehow managed to keep the girls on the farm, but it's not a sad ending either. It's life, that life has good days, and bad days, and life goes on, no matter what happens.

So now, I'll try and work on the review for Shadow Horse, and then finally maybe I'll go back to Thoroughbred. But maybe one of the NewGen books rather than an Ashleigh book for now.

Wearing tight pants and liking it is Dylan's Choice, and who are we to judge him?

Dylan's Choice
Thoroughbred #30
by Dale Gasque
Published: 1998

As we've discovered during the course of this blog, Dale Gasque is probably the best author of the New Generation. After all she's a librarian. Therefore I suppose this isn't shocking. However, just as I feel compelled to pat Gale on the back for her attempts to bring sanity to the Thoroughbred Series with her librarian sense and so forth, I still have to rip this book to shreds. Because this is what I do for fun. Let's take a look at this....


I have little to say about this cover, really, besides the fact that I always thought Christina and Dylan looked like munchkins. If you take Christina off that horse and stick her on the ground, she'd come up to about mid-shoulder on Dakota, and since we go on and on about her being tall I highly doubt that Dakota is the largest horse on the freaking earth. It is the first time in a while that a scene from the book makes it onto the cover, but that is really where the interesting points end and the dull, mundane qualities take over. If we want to nitpick, I can't help but stare at their shoes. Really, the footwear is pretty far off the mark. Also, it looks like someone has used the grass to hide the fact that horses do actually have hooves. Otherwise, you know, whatever.

Will Dylan give up riding for good?

Dylan Becker used to be one of Christina Reese's best friends. They like to do all the same things. He even loved horses as much as she did! But lately, Dylan has been spending more time playing soccer than riding his horse, Dakota. In fact, he's thinking of giving up riding entirely--only little girls like horses, he says.

Christina can't believe it. Has Dylan really outgrown his love of riding? Even worse, has he outgrown their friendship?
The summary is remarkably true to the book. Dylan, like, enjoys other things. He, you know, might want to be well rounded when he grows up. But what is Christina to do? Why can't all her friends be as two-dimensional and narrowly focused as she is? What is a poor, twelve-year-old to do?

That's basically the book. It opens up with Christina being so thrilled that she's having a perfect summer with her perfect horse and her perfect horse-loving friends. Oh, things are so perfectly perfect that this will probably be the high point of her life if Christina isn't very careful. She takes some time to remark to herself how wonderful it is that her friends like what she likes, because having friends who might force her to think outside her carefully constructed box and introduce her to the evil ways of the non-horsey world would be too shocking to fully comprehend. Therefore you see the set up: if one of her friends were to develop an interest in something else and have to juggle their time between what Christina likes and what they also like all hell could potentially break loose. ALL HELL.

That said, let's introduce everyone (again) to Chad. Dale Gasque seems to have some trouble in this department almost immediately, because Chad comes off as a very immature fifteen. He's actually twelve, which is probably the root of my problem with this book. Everyone acts like they're teenagers. Ashleigh even refers to them as teenagers. They are twelve (well, Melanie is thirteen, but you'd never know this and a couple of books ago she was referred to as twelve, so who knows), and after all that happens in this book I am absolutely convinced that Dale Gasque was writing this book with fifteen-year-old kids in mind because SINCE WHEN do twelve-year-olds have Adam's apples and broad shoulders? Is it even possible to have broad shoulders when you're twelve? Is this something twelve-year-old girls look for in twelve-year-old boys or is this just very, very disturbing to all people in general?

Getting back to the plot, Chad is this random kid that Dylan knows and he's all challenging the masculinity of all men (be they twelve or not, I'm sure) in a fifty mile radius. He's just oozing testosterone from every pore, which obviously is going to have ramifications for all involved. Instantly Dylan feels his own tween male identity threatened by the fact that Chad is on a dirt bike and he is in sissy breeches and perched on a castrated horse. Poor, poor Dylan. Then Chad merely smiles at Katie and she is smitten. So the rest of the book involves Christina being dumped in some form or fashion by her bestest friends for this dirt bike riding pseudo fifteen-year-old. You can imagine her frustration.

So because Chad is cool and Dylan wears tight pants, we have this whole dirt bike drama that continues on for many pages. Instead of going out on a horseback ride with Christina, Dylan brings Chad's evil dirt bike and carts her around on that. Christina immediately grows frustrated because she's not the one driving and demands that Dylan teach her to drive so she can cart him around. (Can you see the early trauma developing? Can you?) He teaches her and doesn't tell Chad about this because that would mean he just handed his balls to a girl, and only tweens who wear tight pants would let that happen.

As Chad becomes more and more integrated into the group (learning how to ride to a point that he can get to a river bareback so they can play some sexually frustrated game of chicken in appropriately glossed over Thoroughbred Series standards), Christina becomes more and more upset by the fact that Chad is wooing Dylan away so they can play soccer together and be involved in team sports that build character instead of dutifully doing whatever Christina demands. Chad is fucking up Christina's perfect summer, is the long and the short of it.

So while Christina just stands there and waits for Dylan to become a man and accept whatever fate she's designed for him, he becomes increasingly agitated by the fact that he is not a man (as close as a tween can come to being a man, anyway) and lets this be known in a truly comic display of fucking up repeatedly. Fucking up because he didn't want a girl to beat him in a show jumping contest? Check. Beating up his horse because the horse wouldn't jump a supposedly tricky jump? Check. Yelling "blast off!" while starting a cross country course and subsequently making his horse fall down? Check!

He's well on his way to proving himself to be completely incompetent before he forgets to put galloping boots on Dakota for the show jumping event and winds up cutting his horse up before dumping him with Christina so he can make his soccer play offs. Christina delivers some horrible ultimatum involving forcing Dylan to chose. He can only have one interest, like her, damn it! He got himself into this horrible mess of having two priorities and/or sports he likes and he'll just have to decide which is more important and focus on being driven and humorless like she is. And oh, yeah, she'll take care of Dakota when he decides to go make his own decisions and leaves for the soccer game. Christina is a slave to her one interest, after all. If it involves a horse she's there with bells on. Unless it's racing. In which case she recoils in horror and starts snapping at anyone who will listen that she likes EVENTING. Say it with her. EVENTING.

Anyway, Dylan wins his little soccer tournament and looks all down about it. Deciding between two things any normal person could do with time to spare with a freakishly demanding sort of girlfriend pushing her opinions around with flagrant disregard of anyone's true wishes is hard, after all. Eventually he decides that no, he will not play soccer next year. He will never play soccer again! Christina is happy and Dylan points out to Chad that men are, like, all over in show jumping, and Chad accepts this one line of information and shrugs with a sudden acceptance that is so unlike his character the rest of the time that Dale Gasque really rewrote the Thoroughbred anticlimax. Wonder's Champion has nothing on this book.

Oddities:

  • Just to reiterate, I really cannot believe we're supposed to accept that these kids are twelve. You know how Stacey was always going through boys in The Babysitters-Club and that was supposed to be normal? This eclipses that.
  • The whole swimming in the river thing? Okay, I give you this gem of a line: After ignoring her at first, he finally ducked back down so she could get off. And yes that does involve ducking between Christina's legs.
  • So Dylan gets a lot of grief for liking horses, but Kevin doesn't because "horses are in his blood." You know what it could be? Perhaps Dylan is just a loser and Kevin isn't? Because I don't think kids really differentiate why it's acceptable to make fun of one kid but not the other when they are practically the same people with different names (for all we know).
  • On this same note, Mike suddenly had it hard when he was a kid because he was a boy and liked horses. I do not see this happening at all. It's like someone making fun of Brad for liking horses when he was a kid. Can you see that happening? If someone made fun of Brad for any reason he'd probably file that instance away somewhere and then come back later to financially ruin said person, and he'd laugh with glee while he did it.
  • This book reads like the editors wanted to see if they could market the Thoroughbred Series to boys. I can't see where this book is supposed to appeal to girls. As it is, Christina's attitude is startlingly old fashioned, and she comes off as entirely too domineering and territorial while Dylan shows some completely unflattering inclinations of throwing punches when he gets angry. Nice characteristics for our twelve-year-old heroes to have all around, right?
Well, that's Dylan's Choice. It was minorly more entertaining than the last few installments I've gone through, but mainly in a totally unintentional way. I think I've got some more adventures with Bonnie and Julie of A Horse Called Bonnie next, and then more with the New Generation with A Home for Melanie. Going on that book's cover, I've always wanted to know how Trib wound up in Central Park. I'm sure it was remarkably inefficient and for stunningly pointless reasons.

(Want more? Claire's review of Dylan's Choice is here.)

Jul 6, 2008

Melanie went somewhere during her Last Ride, but we'll never know where.

Melanie's Last Ride
by Alice Leonhardt
Thoroughbred #29
Published: 1998

This is another one of those books with one of those completely ridiculous titles that tries to mean something but just fails horribly. The cover:

I always liked the composition of this cover, despite some rather obvious factors that I seem to have just noticed. For instance, here Christina and Melanie ride Sterling and Trib through a stream in the Pacific Northwest. Because they've decided to ride through a batch of what look to be redwoods in the distance, they've decided to wear their sweaters, which is totally acceptable for Oregon in July. Sure, that's great. Only it's supposed to be Kentucky and I have a feeling that Kentucky doesn't look like this and why are they wearing sweaters when they keep insisting it feels like it's 100 degrees outside in the book? Also, Melanie and Christina appear to be twins. And Trib doesn't look like a pony to me when he's practically Sterling's height. All of this is very unfortunate, because otherwise, you know, it's not bad. I always thought this was Sterling's best cover.

Will Melanie have to leave Whitebrook?

Melanie Graham loves spending time in Kentucky with her cousin Christina. She loves being away from New York City. And most of all, Melanie loves riding! That's why she's determined to win the competition next week. Her dad is flying all the way from New York to watch. Once he sees well how well Melanie rides, he'll let her stay in Kentucky for good.

But then someone begins sabotaging the other riders--and everyone blames Melanie! She might even be disqualified from the competition. Melanie knows that if her dad finds out, he'll make her go back to New York for sure!

Can Melanie prove that she's innocent in time for the big competition?

Oh, you guys, get ready for the Thoroughbred Series meets crappy juvenile mystery genre! Who could possibly be ruining Melanie's perfect summer? Who could possibly care enough (...about something?) that they resort to making the next two weeks of Melanie's life a living hell? Who indeed. I'm sure we'll find out, and I'm sure we'll be disappointed. However, I'm confident that we won't care. At all. So.

Welcome to Camp Saddlebrook, where all your dreams...wait, never mind. The shiny, picture perfect camp experience that was Dale Gasque's attempt to make this series readable has gone through a thorough tarnishing at the hands of Alice Leonhardt, who wrote a good chunk of books in this series and therefore influenced everyone's insanity to a high degree. Actually, I'm pretty sure she's responsible for most of the crazy that goes on in these books.

Anyway, because the New Generation was basically an evil round robin passed between authors with varying ideas of what the written word is supposed to look like, we have Melanie's Last Ride. Somewhere between Camp Saddlebrook and this book, which is about five minutes in TB time, everyone goes through a massive personality shift. Christina goes back to pathetically grumbling about how she wants to be better but isn't, and Melanie...well, Melanie spends all of her time bouncing back and forth between frightening cheerfulness and crushing depression with a generous dose of moping thrown in for good measure. There's also a lot of shrieking during seemingly impossible scenarios, which appears to be Alice's forte. Anyway.

So everyone's coming off the tremendous high that is Eliza buying Flash. Although, you know, like I said everyone suddenly goes off key at the start of this book because what was all nicely tied up in the previous book has to get ripped to shreds in this book so there can be drama and issues and what all. Anyway, everyone goes off to have their lesson and Melanie somehow runs into a nest of yellow jackets. Frieda Bruder, the German riding instructor from Christina's Courage, saves the day by swooping Melanie up all Spiderman-like and running off to hide behind a tree. Yes, that actually happened. So Trib runs off and Dana gets pissy about something because that is her purpose in this book, and before you know it Christina finds her tack trunk riffled through and immediately blames Melanie. Because Melanie is everyone's scapegoat.

I should say that the point system Camp Saddlebrook runs on, the very same one I was so extremely bored by in the previous book and therefore refused to mention in any detail, is like the big plot motivator in this book. So now I'm forced to mention it. I hate having to do this. But this is for the common good, so bear with me. Each group of riders starts out each day with eight possible points. As they go through the day, these points can be taken away with every minor problem -- like accidentally not giving your horse fresh water, or not cleaning the tack each day...stuff like that. Dana is a huge bitch about this system, and uses it to back up her supreme power of Barn A, and no one is really happy about this. So by the time all these pranks start happening that cause point deductions everyone is all pissed because they won't win as the most cleanly group at camp, or something. If it seems pretty stupid and pointless, it is. It really is. Because this is camp, and from my fuzzy memories that's all camp is about. Stupid, pointless. Anyway, these pranks start to happen and somehow everyone knows instinctively to blame Melanie. What does Melanie do? She pouts and feels sorry for herself and cries.

So this goes on for the entire book. One prank happens, so people blame Melanie. She half-heartedly tries to say she wasn't behind the pranks, but no one really believes her. So after every bridle in Barn B gets switched around, Melanie decides she's had enough of this getting blamed for what she didn't do, so she opts to go cause something people can blame her for. The logic here is stunning. Just really very amazing. So she somehow manages to convince Christina to go up to the carriage house to pull a prank on Dylan, Sean and Nathan. This involves sneaking into the bathroom of the boy's room and smearing jelly in their hairbrushes and toothbrushes and so forth. Only they're caught by Sean, who helpfully goes about pulling off the prank for them. Then, to get back at the girls, the boys smear peanut butter on all their toiletries. Everyone blames Melanie, naturally.

Somewhere around here we've got some angst about how Melanie's dad may not show up at the end of camp show, and how Melanie has her great epiphany that she actually hasn't been trying very hard at this whole camp thing and so she resolves to apologize to her teammates for being a general screw up. But then someone goes and lights the feed shed on fire, resulting in high drama and more attempts to pin things on Melanie because one of her flip-flops happened to be by the shed. By this point, Christina et al in their riding group side with Melanie because there's no way Melanie would try to harm a horse. So everyone embraces their internal sleuth and starts hunting around for clues. At one point Melanie decides Gus (the maintenance guy) is behind it all because he's generally grumpy, but after searching through his personal property she just finds a letter indicating he'd been given a bonus, therefore he couldn't possibly be disgruntled, right? So who could it be? Dana is also thrown in there, but she's got the out of recently having her parents split up. So she's suddenly got a reason to be a bitch.

Right around here Sean decides to throw a convenient fit. Because we're nearing that page limit and someone has to be at fault here. Sean is the kind of kid with parents who like to be hard asses and probably were so far from being perfectionists when they were kids that they've developed all sorts of issues to shuffle off on their children. So the result of their procreating is naturally pretty fucked up. Sean's not going to be a pleasant person to be around when he grows up, because on a trail ride he decides to go ballistic on his horse because his parents are meanies with no love for their son who doesn't like football. Or something. So Melanie decides to go confront Sean, who accidentally gives up the fact that yes, he did start the fire to the shed because he wanted to get some attention and finally be the hero. Melanie convinces him to do the right thing and confess, which he does, and Melanie's father shows up, and Sean tells Melanie he'll write her (although I think he just disappears, which is fine with me...he's more than a little creepy) and Melanie and her group suddenly decide that winning isn't everything and everyone screws up in the final show and they probably don't get any awards, which is fine because they feel like winners anyway.

Oddities:
  • At one point Christina's name becomes "Chris-tina."
  • Out on the cross country course, Christina starts grumbling about how the fences, which look freakishly impossible to jump according to Melanie, are "baby fences." Oh, Alice Leonhardt's version of Christina, I've missed you so!
  • Exactly how many books do we have to go through where we learn that winning isn't everything? How many lessons on the same topic do these people have to learn before we can move on to something else already?
Anyway, it's fairly obvious that Sean was the "bad guy" of the book. This book is practically a public statement about parents crushing the hopes and dreams of their children and then having to suffer the consequences when their kids become arsonists. However, you know, it's not that bad of a book (as in, you know, there are far worse installments out there), if you can overlook that whole randomly changing personalities issue.

I can haz messed-up whores... I mean horse- Heartland 2!


Riiight, so I thought we were due for another visit to Heartland. The second volume, After the Storm, is a little less angsty than the first.
With an idea I sort of stole from another blog somewhere, I give you Heartland 2: The Script!


Amy: (sobbing) I miss my mother so much! It is my fault she is dead.
Lou: I am your sister and I am here for you, though I might move back to the city to be with my asshole boyfriend, Carl.
Ty: Look, Amy! We are going to try and fix Spartan, the horse that was involved in the accident! Yay!
Amy: Spartan hates me! He blames me too! I can't do it! I am such a whiny, self-abosorbed bitch!
Lou:Yes you are. I have plans for Heartland that will raise money and you won't listen to them! I feel like I have no place here! Maybe I should go back to the city with my asshole boyfriend, Carl.
Spartan: *attempts to kill Amy*
Grampa: We need to kill him! He is nasty and unpredictable!
Amy: I don't listen to anyone or anything! Spartan is going to be fine! I will just have to do something when you people aren't around to tell me what to do.
Ty: *converts oxygen into carbon dioxide*
Spartan: *rages*
Carl: Hi Lou! I am your smarmy, asshole boyfriend. I just got a job in Chicago and I know you want to move there with me! *g*
Lou: Oh gee. It is such an unclear choice. Maybe I need some proof that you are a wanker before I decide.
Carl: Ok. I will give you time while I hatch up some scheme! Mwahahahaha!
Amy: Gee Spartan, who knew that chasing you around in the middle of a storm would cure you? I bet Monty Roberts would be uber proud of me!
Spartan's Owner: I know you found me but you people gelded my prize special horse and now I don't want him anymore!
Amy: But Spartan loves you with an Undying Love that Only Fictional Equines Have For People!!!
Lou: Forget about that,we have a fundraising barn dance thing to organise! I am so happy that asshole Carl will be there too!
Amy: Wow! I was wrong to doubt you, Lou! This is going to be a success.
Carl: I am back and I know that job offer you got is so great and you're just going to move to Chicago with me, Lou!
Lou: You set me up! I did not see this coming! Fuck off!
Amy: Yay! Now Lou is going to be able to lust after Scott, the hot Vet!
Grampa: The party went so well. Now we have money again! At least for the rest of this book!
Amy: I am going to ride Spartan in a practice round at a show. I know he's not been jumping for more than a week but he has such talent!
Spartan's owner's grandkid: Gerry! You really have a cool name, Geronimo, but we have to give you a stupid nickname instead! I need to ride you in my class. My pony is lame!
Amy: Wow. Spartan loves this girl with a love like no other. I think she must take him home. I know I made Cindy look like an angel in this book, but I am now over blaming myself for my mother's death.

Spartan/Gerry: Neigh!

I have to admit that the books sort of get better after this one, when Amy grows up a little and stops throwing hissy fits all over the show. The twist with Spartan going to the grandkid was kind of sweet if overdone with the whole Special Bond thing. After reading this, I am even more convinced that Heartland and Chestnut Hill have been written by different people. Now that the drama has abated for the time being, I sort of enjoyed this one. It kept my attention for the hour or so it took me to read it. Although, my enjoyment is relative to the last book I read!


More Heartland? Chestnut Hill? Or maybe I will attempt to read Claire's TB Book of Doom, Star's Chance!

Jul 4, 2008

Chestnut Hill: Why TB doesn't suck that much, really!

Ok, so I figured I needed to find something truly terrible, something worthy to add my bit to the awesomeness that is the blog.

I bring you my review of Chestnut Hill 2: Making Strides. (I can’t find the first book, sadly, but I do own 2-6, so be prepared for the nastiness) This series is supposedly written by Lauren Brooke, the one and the same author who wrote Heartland. I, however, suspect that she handed her pen over to some 12 year-old fangirl.

But, there will be plenty of time later for me to go into detail about this, the shittiest horse series ever created. Let’s take a look at the cover!

The Cover

Nothing too much to gripe about here. You can’t go too wrong when you’re working with actual pictures of actual horses. And hey! Tybalt, our equine hero, is actually a bay. Shock. The only thing I hate about this cover is that it tempted me into buying the damn book.

The Blurb

Horses. Friends. Competition. Tradition.

Welcome to Chestnut Hill. An exclusive boarding school set among the rolling hills of Virginia. With a premiere riding program, Chestnut Hill has a long tradition of excellence. Here, the best and brightest learn to shine.

Malory has earned a spolt on the riding team and she’s found a close crew of friends, yet she still questions whether she really belongs at Chestnut Hill. Then a new horse arrives at the stable, and Malory is instantly drawn to him. But Tybalt is weary and defensive. Malory is determined to reach him, and she believes a girl called Amy Fleming can help. When it comes to horses, Malory has always trusted her instincts, and now she’s willing to bet her future at Chestnut Hill that Tybalt has what it takes to win.

It seems all innocent and sweet, right? And, for the most part, accurate. I just love how Brooke shamelessly sticks Amy (Heartland’s main character) in here. It’s kind of like she’s doing the whole self-promotion thing, especially considering how the CH girls worship Amy. Blah. Whatever. This is a bad book in disguise as a passable read.

The Girls

Malory O’Neil: she’s the star of this one. And the scholarship girl, which instantly gives her reason to feel inferior and play the “poor girl” role. She is, of course, naturally talented when it comes to all things equine.

Dylan Walsh: the Stevie Lake of this series, Dylan’s purpose is to make wisecracks and not to take anything seriously. I liked Stevie in the Saddle Club, so I should like Dylan, right? Not so. Dylan is irrational and stupid and annoying. She rides a pony called Morello, that she enjoys pretending is hers. But her aunt is the director of riding at the school, so she gets away with it.

Honey Harper: the girl from England is all demure and cute. Right now, she doesn’t have a special horse but I am sure that will be sorted out in the next book.

Lani Hermandez: well, Lani adds some Latino flavor to the series, I suppose. ‘Cause it can’t just be about rich white girls and their Louis Vuitton accessories! She is just there, for now.

Lynsey Harrison: the uber rich bitch antagonist who always has something nasty to say while wearing some monogrammed item. If Brad Townsend was a girl, he’d be Lynsey. Except, I bet he’d spell his name properly.

The Plot

So it’s Homecoming Weekend at CH, and all the girls in a tizz because they are only getting oatmeal for breakfast and they have to ride in front of the CH Alumnae later. Bitchy comments are exchanged and I can sort of understand why Lynsey acts the way she does. I gotta tell you, these girls can be nasty.

As is tradion with a Lauren Brooke series, Malory’s mother is dead, but it was two years previously, so I am spared from Amy-esque angst for now.

The girls eat hors d’oeuvres and talk shit while waiting for their class. Malory is riding bland old Hardy, who’s only a lowly school pony with the unfortunate show name of Hardy Har Har. I kid you not. Malory rides in the quadrille and then does a course on Hardy. She knocks a pole and we are sad. Plus, it gives certain girls ammo to tease the poor scholarship girl.

There is a Halloween party coming up, where the rich private school girls get to act all slutty with the rich private school boys of St. Kits (Christopher’s), their affiliated school. Malory cannot afford a costume, for shame! So she hides this from her friends. This is real drama, people.

After telling Lani that she reminds her of her grandparents dog, Malory talks about this awesome WonderHorse called Zanzibar, a name Brooke’s neice/daughter/fangirl clearly sucked from a Phantom Stallion book. She used to just randomly climb on this horse’s back in the paddock and ride it around, until her parents decided it might be safer to pay for lessons. Where Malory could ride with tack and under supervision. Like that one’s a real challenge to figure out. Anyway.

Dylan and Malory get asked to try out some new ponies by Mrs. Carmichael, Dylan’s aunt. They go and Malory finds Tybalt, who reminds her of Zanzibar! I’m telling you, a tear rolled down my cheek. Of mirth. Tybalt is all mistrustful, but Malory is convinced she can fix him and turn him into her own Super Special Horse! The horse’s owner gets all pushy and they end up taking Tybalt home with them along with Foxy Lady and Winnie.

But, this is a Lauren Brooke book and things will never go smoothly!

The girls are all excited about using Amy Fleming’s techniques to train Tybalt. You see, they were given a talk by Amy in the first book. Sort of like how some people think by watching a video on Natural Horsemanship, they can suddenly get a green Mustang off the range and train it in one day.

The girls go shopping for costumes and Malory again hides the fact that she can’t afford one. They see boys flirting with Lynsey, who is clearly living up to the whole slut reputation. Malory thinks of Caleb, a guy she used to ride with who will be at the party. He is hot. Like…. HOT. As far as Malory is concerned, anyway. Clearly she has not met Brad Townsend, who surpasses all standards of hotness like Glory does other racehorses.

Eventually, Lani confesses that she has no costume and the girls dress her up as Cleopatra. But no! Lynsey’s minion, Patience, is dressed the same! Turns out, Caleb, the hot guy, was supposed to be Patience’s date, but confuses her for Malory. Drama! Malory is all hurt and thinks that Caleb doesn’t remember her. I don’t care.

So, Tybalt has to be ridden at some stage. Lynsey gets the honor. She gets dumped and throws a prissy tantrum that the horse isn’t worthy of Chestnut Hill. Now we are scared Tybalt will get sent back to where he came from.

Hardy comes up lame and Malory has no horse to ride for the upcoming interschools competition. She asks Mrs. C if she can try Tybalt out, much to my shock. Or not. She rides and she does terribly and Mrs. C says she will have take Foxy Lady to the show instead, so all is not lost.

But, then we all have the epiphany that Amy Fleming can help! Yay! Amy works her magic with massage, join-up and herbal stuff. Tybalt is a totally new animal, thanks to love and all that crap. Malory rides him again and they do well.

Tybalt is so great and talented, that mere horses pale in comparison. Malory rides him a lesson and gets permission to take him to the show, which is always good to do on a pony that they know nothing about that hasn’t been worked hard in ages and ages. I am so glad there are books like this to instill good horse sense into impressionable young minds!

At the show, Tybalt freaks out and Caleb rescues Mallory from certain death. They debate about scratching him, but Malory cannot give up! Her ride goes badly and they mess up the course. Malory is sure that Tybalt will be sent away.

But, this is is aimed at children and we must all have our happy endings. Of course Tybalt gets to stay at CH! Mallory now has her very own special horse… aside from the technicality that she doesn’t own him, of course.

Monique’s Name-Dropping-o-meter! (Becuase it happens. A lot.)

  • Scooby Doo
  • X-Files
  • The Flintstones
  • Buffy the Vampire Slayer
  • Rolex- the watch
  • The Addams Family
  • The Four Seasons

Points of Interest

  • One of their classmates is studying poetry by Silvia Plath. I had no idea they covered that in middle school. I should send my kids to CH!
  • Typical breakfast fare at CH is: French toast, waffles, muffins, THREE kinds of sausage (would that be beef, pork and vegan?) and fresh fruit!
  • What is it with horse books and fucking blueberry muffins?
  • I seriously hope I never compare a guy’s breeding to a horse’s.


I suppose I should stick with it and read CH3: Heart of Gold next. I warn you though, the books get suckier and suckier.